Chuffy
Posted : 7/20/2007 6:44:19 PM
ORIGINAL: Ixas_girl
Was that the episode that featured a white (lab?shepherd) that belonged to a woman in a wheelchair and her 2 sons, or am I mixing episodes?
The scene in the yard reminded me of how handlers approach and capture feral animals. He kept limiting where the dog could go, till the dog submitted to capture. As I recall they ended up in a trashy side yard full of debris [:'(].
No that was not the episode.
CM did explain what he was doing and while I do not remember the exact wording he di dexplain that part of the technique was to tire the dog first. He was not just trying to make the dog submit to capture. He was deliberately keeping the dog on the move, using a long object (possibly a broom) as an extension of himself and movin g towards the dog to make the dog move again and again. At the end of this part of the session he explained that now the dog was tired, but he (CM) was not.
I wish I could remember the name of the dog.... I think it was pale, it was female and it was one of two dogs belonging to that owner. I think they were crossbreeds. The other was brown and whiteI am sorry I cannot remember more. I did feel when watching this that this technique caused undue stress to the dog. This was one of the moments when I did not enjoy CMs show.
In any case, CM is not there to "capture" the animal. IMO his job is to first gain the animal's trust and respect and I
believe that he should do this by encouraging the animal to approach of its own free will. This is purely my opinion mind.... and wth do I know.
I think I understand what mudpuppy is saying and if I have understood correctly then I agree. MP is not suggesting that ANYONE beats the animals in their care. I believe that what they are trying to say is, just because you do a practise calmly does not make it a good practise! Lots of practises can be carried out calmly and still be wrong. Beating an animal would be one example. "running an animal down" would (
IMO) be another. For someone who did not know any better, or purely for purposes of containing the animal then fair enough, but CM is no novice at dog handling and I think he should have had a better trick up his sleeve. Further, his purpose was not to simply catch and contain the dog a la AC. He was trying to rehabilitate it. Different kettle of fish entirely. If an animal needs to be caught, then you use the quickest, most humane method you can. If an animal needs to be rehabbed, speed should not, under normal circumstances, be at the top of the list of priorities.
I only meant to clarify and it became a novel. Sorry.