I've noticed a few people on the board have that Ruffwear web harness. I've been looking at harnesses as I can't say I'm particularly thrilled with collars and what happens with collars in emergencies. I have had moments where I've lifted Penny entirely off the ground by her collar to get her out of the road of a charging dog. It's why I stopped using check chains (what can I say, it was the done thing and still is in this country), but really, a collar isn't much better. But then, Penny has a car harness and she really hates walking in it. She always gives me this look like she's saying "Aren't you going to take it off so I can walk properly?". Anyway, I saw the Ruffwear one and it seemed like it allowed for normal movement while still being near to impossible for the dog to get out of. I was thinking for the new dog when he's big enough for one (they're $90 over here!), but then I thought about how often it would have been handy with Penny to have a handle to safely pull her out of trouble (read, a body of water she jumped into but discovered she couldn't climb out of), and these days we need to pick her up a lot and now I'm thinking I should try one with her.
What are people's experiences with the harness? How does it go if the dog jumps into stinky water with it on.