Unfortunately when people don't 'understand' something they are either afraid of it or mock it, or both. And often such things -- because they are beyond the realm of easy understanding -- wind up being categorized as "unGodly". Usually that's fear talking (and I'm not being a communicator -- that's just basic humanity).
We humans tend to have such a high opinion of ourselves that we like to say that, again ... things not easily understood ... are 'bunk'. But I often giggle because I think it's supremely stupid to think that other species don't communicate *and* that we can't learn to communicate with them.
I think inter-species communication is far beyond that often-abused word "psychic". When communication focuses on that new-agey "psychic" stuff, then it can get into that fringey 'bunk' area.
But for heavens sake -- it's a whole package. YES IT CAN BE LEARNED. I'm so glad to hear folks talk about this. It can also be taught ... to your dog or to anyone else. I never talk about this much -- because like Ratsicles I don't like the negative some folks place on it. But it's simply part of how I communicate with animals and with people.
I'm going to emhasize here that PART of this is simple observance. And this is the thing most humans miss -- part of the way dogs 'communicate' with each other is body language. How 'tense' the skin/fur is ... the position of the ears ... how wide the eyes are open and how the eyes flick back and forth ... tail position and body tension/structure/position generally.
ANY species ... including humans ... use that as part of their communications. Shoot, carnival 'fortune tellers' and con men have been using these sorts of observations to make their living for years!!! If you are simply observant of such things it makes understanding someone far easier.
Observe two people talking sometime -- say the couple across from you at a restaurant -- you don't have to know what they are actually saying, in words, to glean a WHOLE LOT from the 'conversation' -- who is tense? Who is bored or worried or nervous -- is it a true conversation or is one person doing all the 'talking' and the other person is merely nodding their head but are actually miles away?
You don't have to use WORDS to understand those things. You just have to LOOK.
But then -- when you add the mental -- it gets so much deeper.
The first time I did this with Billy (and I've been 'talking to the animals' since *I* was a little kid as well -- I'm an only child, which probably helped -- and if you're alone you talk to anyone!! Gekkos and frogs and fish!!) -- we'd just adopted Billy and he had decided pretty quick that Mom was the cuddly, snuggly one. He was quite bemused by the communication Foxy and I had (Foxy the Mostlie Sheltie -- then a 17 1/2 year old sheltie/corgi mix). Foxy could 'think' to me and indicate if he was thirsty, needed to go 'out' etc. Affection was also a big part of it.
One day about 2 weeks after Billy had come to live with us, Billy was lying on the bed with me and I decided to gently 'try' some mental stimulation. We were lying on the bed, face to face and I just pressed my forehead against his. mmmmmm - NICE Mom!! He was completely relaxed.
I just focused my thots to say 'Billy, you're a good boy!' -- HIS HEAD CAME UP, and stared at me. I smiled and repeated the thot.
UTTER PANIC ON HIS FACE and he lept off the bed and FLEW to the other room.
I simply kept up positive thots and particularly loving, affectionate thots and quickly he got used to it. Within just a few weeks, that pre-goodnight forehead to forehead time was his favorite. Rather than fearing it, he quickly learned to lean into it and press harder to express his affection for me.
Oh boy -- now a bunch of folks are gonna think Callie's truly lost it this time. but I haven't -- it's just not something I talk a lot about with other humans.
I will say this -- I'm probably more spirit-centered and -- oh I hate this word, but -- "religious" than most of you know. It's not fortunetelling -- it's simply tapping talents most of us don't even know we have. We 'think' to God or speak softly and call it prayer ... but if you really think about it, that's kinda 'psychic' isn't it? That, I guess, was my first clue that this might not be a 'bad' thing but rather a good one.
I don't mean to turn this into a religious discussion, and I don't mean to offend anyone. But honestly, for many people taught to 'fear' this kind of thing from the cradle up, I think it's important to understand it might not be the "voodoo" or "evil" thing that a lot of people assume.
Holistic practitoners call it "intent" - but it's just the ability to reassure a wild thing that you don't mean it 'harm'. It's how some of us can handle wild things and not get hurt or bitten.