Jan
Posted : 8/22/2006 12:02:06 AM
I feel that if your dog cannot handle these situations, they should not be put into them.
The problem here is that the only way to teach your dog TO handle these situations is to get out and socialize your dog and give your dog a chance to get comfortable in these situations.
One of the toughest things I ever did with Jessie during the early Cujo days when she disliked and distrusted pretty much everyone was forcing myself to take her places, when all I wanted to do was hide her in the house and never let anyone near her or her near anyone so nothing bad could happen.
Don't get me wrong, I kept her on a short leash and I watched her like a hawk. But I took her EVERYWHERE, not despite the fact that she didn't much like people, but BECAUSE of it. First we got the obedience really strong, but then a big part of her training was going to street fairs, shopping centers, banks, parks, public places with dogs and people and even kids. I constantly exposed her to places and people, watching her carefully but working to help her develop a comfort level in myriad settings.
And today, she's a therapy dog. She sociable, confident, happy and good with people.
By contrast, I know a guy at work who had a similar situation with his dog, same breed, same issues, but he agreed with your sentiments. So he never took the dog anywhere. He had a backyard BBQ last week, and the dog was on a leash the whole time, even outside, and no one could get near him because he snarled and snapped at everyone. When I saw him, all I could think was, "This is how Jessie would have turned out if I hadn't forced myself to take her everywhere, worked with her, socialized and trained her. This is the same dog, only whose owner made different choices."
And I came home from the party so grateful that I had done what I'd done with Jess.
Yes, you have to be extremely careful. You have to be able to think and move quickly, and be rude if required. But to me, doing this often means giving your dog a very special gift -- teaching him/her to be sociable and good with people so he/she can experience so much more of life, spend more time with you, etc.
It's not that I don't understand your sentiments or take the safety issues seriously, but I also feel like you cripple your dog by not socializing it -- and it's even MORE important to do this is the dog has some issues.
Jan