ron2
Posted : 6/22/2006 6:24:14 PM
This guy doesn't seem to understand pack behavior as well as he thinks he does. Alpha position in the pack means first chance to eat, first chance at mating rights with the alpha female, but it doesn't mean that each member of the pack receives whatever, food, attention, play time, at the express permission of the alpha. I would suggest that he actually observe some wolves before he comments any further on pack behavior. I do agree that unwanted behavior should be addressed immediately. I know some trainers even advocate euthanasia for an ill-tempered dog. But I would not beat or choke a dog. I have, however, used a scruff and eye-lock with Shadow and it has worked. It was not painful to him but was similar to what he would have received from momma dog. And I didn't use it at every instant, only in dire circumstances, such as when he was trying to pick a fight with my in-law's Lhasa Apso. Afterward, he followed only me and wouldn't look at her even whens he started barking again. And, I've controlled him better with treat-based obedience since then. That is, I don't beat him or shake him and I get the best obedience out of him with treats but he does know that I am the big dog.
I also disagree with this guy who's solution to everything is shove them in a crate and never allow contact with anyone or anything again. All that does, IMO, is foster a fear of the unknown or strange.
Here's how I dealt with Shadow rearing up on guests (all in a gesture of exuberant love, btw). A few times I would pull him off of them and hold him by his scruff, not hard, but a way to control his movements, as if he were in harness and leash. Other times, a "no." Patience on my part for 20 minutes helped him realize that he wasn't going to get what he wanted and that I could outlast him and he finally settled down and laid down. Because I am the big dog. Thanks to my mom, I could give stubborn lessons to a mule. And I would keep correcting him, whether it is "no," or physically pulling him away and introducing a sit or down, with commands I already developed with treats, until he finally realizes that this is how we behave in company. And patience has paid off. He is more ready to obey these days, through simple repetition in different circumstances. So, when I say that I scruff him, I don't mean I grab a handful of neckhide and lift him off of the ground. It just takes the place of harness and leash if he's not in them.
And, I'm not impressed with the way the guy browbeats people earnestly asking questions.
I was raised by my mother with avoidanceor negative conditioning. I obeyed to avoid getting whipped or hit in the face, which where the standard punishments. Look what happened to me.[

]