Boerboel

    • Gold Top Dog
    ORIGINAL: Scout in Canada

    Espence, mrv was replying to AwsomeDog's post about a DA rottie. See above.


    Ups i fixed it already [:D]
    • Gold Top Dog
    ORIGINAL: espencer

    ORIGINAL: Scout in Canada

    Espence, mrv was replying to AwsomeDog's post about a DA rottie. See above.


    Ups i fixed it already [:D]

     
    I'm too quick. [;)]
    • Gold Top Dog
    actually the term I used was applied behavior analysis.   I did not indicate a species.  The response was written to answer the question of how I might perceive applied behavior analysis being used on a dog aggressive rottweiler.
    • Gold Top Dog
    ORIGINAL: mrv

    In such a case, I would suggest that a multiple phase approach would be best.  A training activity in which obedience commands are emphasised so a new default behavior is in place.  Distraction training with dogs at a distance in safe situations (barriers between animals).  In this phase the breaking of eye contact would be one facet, as would redirection to the default behaviors.  Keeping the dog in motion and focused on intereaction with the handler.  As the training progresses, different variables would be systematically changed to promote the generalization of the behavior across environments.


    Ok, first you say all that . Then you follow with this.

    I do not work with serious aggression cases.  I refer those out.


    If that's how it's done, and not just how you think it's done, why aren't you doing this with serious cases? Why send them away if it's just that simple? Oh, and just how long would it take you to actually help a serious case doing it that way? Oh that's right, you don't.

    I do work with reactive and what are perceived as agressive dogs in a class setting.  I have been teaching public obedience classes for 15 years and typically, I get the hard dogs.


    The act of aggression from a dog, is, aggression. Now there's different levels of aggression. And actually, I think it's hard dogs your sending away.

    As to my qualifications, I am trained as a behaviorist... I use the principles daily in my work... I work in schools.  I see some of the same arguments in that setting about techniques that occur on the board.


    That's great! Where was it you became a trained dog behaviorist? Or Animal behaviorist? Schools? Dog schools or people schools?
    • Gold Top Dog
    wow...there is simply no answer that will not provoke a rude explosive fit from you is there?
    • Gold Top Dog
    It is apparent to me that you do not wish to debate,,,so be it.   If you would reread my posts, you will see that I have not called myself a certified animal behaviorist.  I said I was trained in applied behavior analysis. 
     
    I have seen the techniques done and in a class situation there is no safe and appropriate way in which to deal with a truly dog aggressive dog,,so yes I take the responsible course and refer them out.  I fail to see what is so wrong about that.
     
    I fail to see how the use of a proven technology in multiple venues where behavior change is the desired outcome would be cause for such a set of negative comments.
     
     
    • Gold Top Dog
    ORIGINAL: Scout in Canada

    It is a common problem that people misinterpret what positive reinforcement is. It is not a treat, or a toy, or a pet, or praise in an of itself. It is only positive based on the impact it has on behavior.


    Absolutely - both you and mrv have stated what is, to +R trainers, the obvious. 


    So true. It's not positive reinforcement if it's not working. People often say "+R doesn't work for my dog because there are more interesting things to him than the treat I'm holding". Than you're not doing +R! Pick a reward that does impact their behavior. I think Ed uses squirrel-chasing or some variant of that as a reward for his dogs. They are drivey, they love chasing prey, and that can be used in exchange for the behavior he wants. Sorry Ed if I'm confused there or thinking of someone else. I'm pretty sure you had mentioned that at some point.


    Sometimes, we have to work pretty hard to find the reinforcer (I like that word so much better than "treat" [;)]), but the object for the trainer is to find a reinforcer that the dog perceives as valuable, so I'm with Ed - use the squirrels if that's what it takes. [:)]
    • Gold Top Dog
    mrv,
     
    I enjoy your posts. You are a model of exempliary behavior, courtesy, and civility.
     
    [;)]
     
     
     
     
    • Bronze
    Many moons ago, a poster, named Sunny, offered dilligent and specific training advice to me how best to deal with my fearful, reactive Gypsy.  I will always be grateful for the assistance given.  Over time, however, Sunny's contributions suffered because her delivery and discourse  began to drown  any pertinent and relevant information she was sharing because it became impolite. Such a shame, too. I am afraid, Awsome Dog, you can hardly be heard, but only felt, when you continue to poke a "cyber" finger into the chests of other members in your zest and zeal to be heard....or even understood.
     
    back to topic...as they say
    • Gold Top Dog
    ORIGINAL: mrv

    It is apparent to me that you do not wish to debate,,,so be it.   If you would reread my posts, you will see that I have not called myself a certified animal behaviorist.  I said I was trained in applied behavior analysis.


    And yet you talk as though you are the behavior expert and what Cesar does is wrong. And *you* *yourself* can't even say how you've handle those types of cases, you can only say what you would, might, possibly do with those cases. Well again, you send them to someone else. So how exactly does being "trained in applied behavior analysis" make you right and Cesar wrong? How much of your training was done *with dog behavior*?

    I have seen the techniques done and in a class situation there is no safe and appropriate way in which to deal with a truly dog aggressive dog



    ETS So why don't you help them out of the class?

    so yes I take the responsible course and refer them out.  I fail to see what is so wrong about that.


    And yet you sit in judgement of someone who actually rehabilitates "truly dog aggressive dogs".

    I fail to see how the use of a proven technology in multiple venues where behavior change is the desired outcome would be cause for such a set of negative comments.


    Please, lets not play that game.
    • Gold Top Dog
    ORIGINAL: pndhounds

    Many moons ago, a poster, named Sunny, offered dilligent and specific training advice to me how best to deal with my fearful, reactive Gypsy.  I will always be grateful for the assistance given.  Over time, however, Sunny's contributions suffered because her delivery and discourse  began to drown  any pertinent and relevant information she was sharing because it became impolite. Such a shame, too. I am afraid, Awsome Dog, you can hardly be heard, but only felt, when you continue to poke a "cyber" finger into the chests of other members in your zest and zeal to be heard....or even understood.

    back to topic...as they say


    I simply state my opinions like all the rest. Perhaps you should be pointing that "cyber" finger in another direction. It is IMO wrong to come on here, sit in judgement of, and bash someone who can do what you don't, won't, or can't do. The only people I am in conflict with here are the same ones that just can't stand he's proving so many wrong. Which I guess is why it's eating at spiritdogs so much , she's still pm-ing me *something about pistols at dawn lol* who knows, who cares, I do not. Which, now that I think of it, while I say I don't care for it, I don't bash it. That's really odd. Where was I? Oh! So they come here simply to dump on him. How many times did it have to be pointed out that "Cesar" the man, the person, "Cesar Milan" Does not! say he's a behaviorist. And yet! the argument continued. Rediculous.
    • Gold Top Dog
    His own website for his soley owned business "the psycology center" labels him as a dog behavior specialist.  Behavior-list, hello awsomedog - same thing!  Don't even try to say that he has no input to what that site has to say.
    • Gold Top Dog
    ORIGINAL: luvmyswissy

    His own website for his soley owned business "the psycology center" labels him as a dog behavior specialist.  Behavior-list, hello awsomedog - same thing! 


    That's your opinion only, sorry But I disagree, they're not the same thing. Your putting your twist on it because you got nothing else. But keep digging.
    • Gold Top Dog
    Anyway, trying to get the conversation back to some useful topic....
     
    Awsomedog, have you read or seen the book Scaredy Dog? I mentioned it a few posts ago. The intro to the book describes the author's DA dog whose condition was only worsened by the actions of a behaviorist ('hanging' him by his collar in response to his aggression). She slowly rehabbed him through desensitization much as mrv described. What do you think of this?
    • Gold Top Dog
    I know it is a dead horse, but it one I can not resist at the moment.[;)]
     
    Specifically to Awsomedog.
     
    If you will reread my posts, I never bashed Cesar Milan, his approaches or his skills.  Go back and check.  I objected to his mass media impact which may put people at risk.  This is of concern to me because of breed specific legislation which will likely name my breeds of choice soon.
     
    I offered a strategy for aggression that I have implemented and that I have seen implemented by others. 
     
    To attack a person's intent, skills because they dont match Cesar's....isnt that the pot calling the kettle back.