calliecritturs
Posted : 5/28/2010 12:01:13 AM
Dawnben
Thats funny calliecritters because that is where I get most of my information on diet is from Dr. Jean Dodd.http://www.canine-epilepsy.com/doddsnutrition.html. Hear is an article on the importance of diet and nutrition and how it affects the immune system. She also writes for the whole dog journal and wrote a great article about veggie diets. It is the only thing that helped my foxhound.
I didn't say a veggie diet was impossible - I said it was difficult. And I still say most dogs don't absorb enough taurine from supplementation, nor do they get enough L-Carnitine. Even with meat in his diet I *still* supplement Billy heavily on both taurine and L-Carnitine.
Dawnben
I am just skeptical of vets that test and still prescribe meds when they dont find anything definitive wrong with a dog.
I'm only skeptical if the vet isn't following a logical path -- which this vet is -- and there are no good, cost-effective tests FOR allergies. The less expensive blood tests are just plain unreliable and the ones that do work are extremely costly. Some vets ARE actually smart enough to realize that not all diagnoses should be nor can be purely the answer from a test.
It used to be called "the medical arts" because doctors and veterinarians didn't just look at a test but they looked at the patient's age, history and they matched that up with what's known, what's logical and their own diagnostic skills. It's rare to see a vet do that today, but not impossible.
Dawnben
The meds lower the immune system and do more damage while they do nothing to correct the problem and often harm the dog
I agree absolutely -- but you also have to get the dog stable. If you re-read what I said I stressed that antihistamine likely is NOT the answer. Short term it may get the dog thru until a better way can be seen.
See, you can't just take off and do herbs on your own. Most people don't have the knowledge of them nor do they have the veterinary knowledge to really know what is and isn't safe in an herb. In particular, TCVM uses incredibly good herbs -- most of them far far more on target than the herbs we have here in the west. It's difficult, at this point in time, to FIND a good quality source for herbs -- and it's NOT going to your local grocery store or pharmacy to get whatever "generic" style herb that's easy to find. The quality unfortunately tends to be inferior. So getting a GOOD herb is critical.
But honestly first, she needs to make SURE that the thyroid isnt' the culprit before she starts bouncing around with herbs or food. They're both good good things (I home cook for 3 dogs, trust me -- most kibble isn't worth pulling off the shelf in my opinion) BUT first she needs to eliminate the thyroid as being a potential contributor.
Because if it IS the thyroid, it can go undetected for ages -- while they wind up jumping from novel protein to novel protein (only increasing the allergy load on the dog). So elminate that from the beginning, and NO ONE is better at that than Dr. Dodds. (and she'd gonna tell you that ruling out thryoid problems is Job #! -- and trust me, Jean would tell you that in spades!!!
It's simply part of good diagnostic practice -- there is no "good" pharmaceutical answer to allergies. Just approach it from a sensible position and make SURE you don't miss a vital bit of information before you embark on as big a deal as "diet" can be. Once she's sure that the thryoid is NOT a source of problem ... THEN try diet and herbs.
But even then, I'd a whole lot rather Deb had the RIGHT vet advising her rather than just venturing out on her own. good holistic vets are not hard to find -- BAD ones are abundant, but a Good holistic vet is a pearl!!