ron2
Posted : 7/12/2008 10:12:16 AM
Let me offer myself as an example and what I learned.
I had a cat we named Misty (after the song by Harold Arlen.) "Look at me ... I'm as helpless as a kitten up a tree. Never know my hat from my glove ... I'm just misty and too much in love..."
Anyway, I fed her Delicat by Purina. For 16 years. When she was 16, she looked a little weak and kept coughing up. I thought it was hairballs. I took her to the vet and analysis showed that she had diminished kidney function. So, the vet had me feed her Purina NF. NF stands for Nitrogen Free. Here's why.
The by-product of consuming animal protein is the release of nitrogen from the source meat. All animals have nitrogen in their bloodstreams because we breathe it in the air. The earth's atmosphere is mostly nitrogen with some oxygen, plus a few trace gases like argon. Anyway, the released nitrogen is filtered out by the kidneys and passed out in urine. This happens whether you feed kibble or raw meat. Maybe even moreso with raw meat as you get the full load of nitrogen in the blood that's in the meat plus whatever residual that's in the cells of muscle tissue.
As any creature ages, organs tend to decrease in function. It's called getting old. When the kidneys don't do their job as well (as I said, not always a result of improper food but can be a result of being ancient) the nitrogen backs up into the system, creating nausea (the coughing up and vomiting) and lethargy (the lack of energy). They don't feel pain like you and think of it. They just don't feel as well. The reason for the special diet of Purina NF is that the protein in it (and the animal still needs protein) is from grain and vegetable, which do not haev nitrogen in the protein chain molecules that they provide. So, the animal gets the protein without the nitrogen load. This takes a burden off of the kidneys. My cat lived one more year. By the way, when a cat has had failing kidneys, they will eventually have drastic kidney failure. That is inevitable. An NF food can delay the inevitable for a while. At just about 17 years old, Misty had drastic kidney failure. I had her put to sleep in my arms as I will not allow a pet of mine to suffer needlessly. That was 02-17-05 and I still get a chill from that. If I were 119 years old, I'm betting that my kidneys might be slowing down, too.
Anyway, if I were you, I would trust the vet. And there are other kidney formulas on the market if you don't like Science Diet. If you go out and try to feed her raw or high animal protein food, you will increase the problem. I know cats are obligate carnivores. And they can consume the non-animal protein in a special kibble because kibble is not like eating a breast of chicken. All ingredients are ground to a fine powder or paste before being pressed into the extrusion machine. And not one source has all the required proteins, either.