GoldenAC
Posted : 4/7/2008 7:46:04 PM
HoundMusic
Interesting. Do you breed yourself? I can tell a pet quality pup right off the bat, around 6 weeks - sometimes sooner if it's apparent the pup has an obviously snippy muzzle or poor tail carriage/set. Those defects tend to show up quite early on & stand out like a sore thumb. Temperament is also a definer of pet quality - more submissive pups are apparent @ 4-5 weeks and they are not suitable for a breeding program. There are some pups, while still in the whelping box, who stand out with exceptional round bone, nice full muzzles & then go on to have superior structure/temperament, nose orientation, intelligence. I'll mark these as potential show, field or breeding quality (and lol, yes, they are out of sire/dam who are not show CHs - they're not even show bred). And you can believe that is no con. I do not often have homes lined up for my pups, the most I have is interest, because I don't even take deposits before a litter is on the ground. Interested parties don't always choose to purchase a pup from you! Waiting list is not an indicator of a good breeder, and ther eis nothing, I mean absolutely nothing wrong with advertising pups as pet/show quality ...
I have not bred a litter yet, but I am considering breeding Selli in a year or so after she completes her MX and MXJ. I have many friends who breed for performance, show and field. From what I have observed, it is easy to tell if a puppy is pet quality, but determining if a puppy is really show quality is something that occurs after the puppy has grown up. I know Shelties who look wonderful as puppies but grow too big (quite frequent) or whose ears don't tip properly. I know a lab puppy who had great potential but wound up with a bad gait. And boy, all the Goldens who are bred by great breeders out of Ch stock who are show picks and co-owned by the breeder but for one reason or another (like lack of coat, lack of size or bone, missing teeth) turn out to not be show quality.
It may be different in Beagles, but in Goldens, it is remotely possible but highly improbable, that a dog that is not out of show lines will do well in dog shows which is what "show quality" refers to. I have seen many breeder or general "buy a puppy" listing websites where individual golden puppies are advertised as "show quality." No information on the puppy's pedigree is given, or if it is, the pedigree only shows titled dogs two or three generations back. It is hard, if not impossible for me to believe that these puppies have any chance in the breed ring. And yes, I believe these ads are a scam. If you have a person who has no experience with show dogs, but sees a "breeder" call a puppy "show quality" they are likely to believe that claim and they have no knowledge to evaluate the claim or the puppy. The breeder can call any puppy they want to "show quality," it doesn't mean the puppy is, and if the "breeder" is unscrupulous, they may claim a puppy is "show quality" to up the demand for their puppies.