NicoleS
Posted : 3/17/2008 8:21:48 PM
We've had great luck with both Allstate and State Farm -- definitely shop around, when we moved out of state, Allstate used to be the cheapest in NY but they were more in PA and State Farm was hundreds of dollars less per year. I'm also 23, with a currently clean driving record (they only go back 3 yrs) as is DH. And, our renter's insurance is about $110/YEAR for about $45k coverage, and because of the multi policy discount, we save about $90/year on our car insurance, so it's nearly FREE.
I definitely like to go with a "better" insurance company -- we've had progressive and others in the past, and I totally feel that I am in better hands with one of the upper companies, like Allstate, State Farm, etc. Yeah it just my opinion and we've only had one claim while on our own insurance, but still. The cost isn't that much where I would go to a lower level insurance company without a real office. However, if someone has a lot of accidents and tickets and one of the big name companies won't insure them, then it's a different story. But even things like Progressive and Geico aren't more than $5-10 a month different.
Oh, and Allstate was still more expensive even with the safe driver discounts. But, as I said, it totally depended on state since that wasn't the case at all when we lived in NY. I'd get a quote or two every year, since as you get older and closer to 25 your insurance will keep going down.