Niki Seich
Posted : 4/19/2006 4:34:33 PM
I am one who does NOT think crate training is a bad idea at all... or that it is cruel... as long as some factors are thought through. 1. if the dog isn't potty trained and you're not going to be home, and if you don't have a secure room or area that they can have accidents in/on a crate is the next best thing. 2. if it's a puppy, puppies chew and eat things they shouldn't... they can chew cords and be electrocuted or find poisonous substances and consume them.. a crate put in a well selected area would stop that. I could go on and on about this but those are the two main things that I look at when I mention crate training.
ALTHOUGH, I am a house wife... so I am home almost 24/7 we don't do big vacations or any of that stuff, and we really only leave to get groceries, rarely go out to a movie and or dinner, or when we take the dogs on trails for a walk and or to the petstores with us! [

] My dogs consider their crates *their* place, it is where they go for bedtime, where they go for a time out, and usually where they go when they are tired, or afraid of someone that comes to the house for a visit. I consider dogs "den animals" they love their own spot to go and curl up for a good nap. I dunno about other toy dogs, but when mine get scared for whatever reason, their crate is their retreat... they feel safe and not bothered there. I made sure from the time they were puppies to know that their crates were *their* area their spot.. and they treat it as such.

If i wasn't such a horrible tosser and turner at night, they'd be snoozing in bed right along with my husband and I...but since I could easily hurt them... they have their crates to sleep in with their beds and toys. If my pomies ever fully potty train, then sure they will be loose in my bedroom 24/7 but the two are still very young (8 months old) they are almost completly potty trained but can easily still have an accident and my other female was obviously never potty trained and since in my situation I rent from my parents crate training is my best option for now while they obviously cannot be 100% trusted outside their crate. <---they DO not potty in their crate unless they absolutly cannot hold it.
I think that being gone for hours on end for a younger dog (puppy) is a really hard way to train a dog.. but it obviously can be done. If I was in a situation like this, I'd probably turn my kitchen into a large area the dog could be in while I wasn't home... atleast until it was potty trained... and mean while the floor would be placed with puppy pee pads and or newspaper, and when I got home from work I'd work on training it potty training how ever I chose until they eventually got the hang of it. [

]
But in my experience and from what other pomie (and toy owners) have told me, small dogs are pretty complicated to fully potty train... so all I can do is wish the original poster good luck with their future doggie and I hope if/when you do get a pup or dog that no matter what you don't give up on it, because most of it's problems will probably be from being home alone a lot ie; pottying in house, bad behavior (distruction of your stuff etc), barking...