Sad Animal Cruelty Case

    • Gold Top Dog

    Sad Animal Cruelty Case

    A college student at Cornell is charged with abusing his roommates dog.  The dog chewed on some speaker wires, so this guy decided to punish her in his sick and twisted manner.  The rest of the details are below, but be warned that the details are disturbing.

    [linkhttp://www.topix.net/forum/city/belmont-ma/TDK411JK50F6JEV1M]http://www.topix.net/forum/city/belmont-ma/TDK411JK50F6JEV1M[/link]

    This is a link of a video of the dog:  [linkhttp://www.news10now.com/content/top_stories/default.asp?ArID=98661]http://www.news10now.com/content/top_stories/default.asp?ArID=98661[/link] 

    Ithaca Journal March 16, 2007
    Cornell student charged with torturing animal
    Man allegedly beat, poured bleach on dog
    From Journal Staff Reports
    ITHACA — A 23-year-old Cornell student from the Boston area, taking care of another person's dog for a night, was charged with beating it and pouring bleach on it, leaving it with diminished eyesight for life, the Ithaca Police Department said.
    Alexander H. Atkind, 23, of 710 Stewart Ave., Apt. 8 and of Lexington, Mass., was charged with "overdriving, torturing and injuring animals” in violation of a section of the state Agriculture and Markets law. The offense is a misdemeanor. He was released with a ticket to appear in Ithaca City Court on Wednesday, March 21.
    According to an Ithaca police report, the case began when the owner of the dog contacted the police department at 4 a.m. Saturday, March 10. The dog's owner told the investigating officer he'd left his dog, later identified as a black-and-white, 30-pound Labrador-pit bull mix named Princess, in the care of Atkind while spending Thursday night, March 8, at a family member's house.
    On Friday, March 9, the dog's owner talked to Atkind on the phone, who said the dog had chewed on a speaker wire Atkind owned. Atkind told the owner he'd beaten Princess, and poured bleach and laundry detergent on her, but the dog was all right. Late Friday, the owner came home and found the dog severely beaten and called police.
    The officer found the apartment and kennel area in disarray, with dog food, bleach and detergent spilled. The dog had a laceration 1 inch by 2 inches wide, and some of its skull was showing through, according to the officer's report. He called the Cornell University veterinary hospital and took the dog there for evaluation. The next day, he was told by the attending veterinarian that the dog suffered chemical burns to its face, eyes, back, groin area and paws. It would likely have diminished eyesight the rest of its life, and it had blood in its stool, probably from ingesting some bleach by licking itself.
    The officer called Atkind, who admitted beating the dog, and agreed to come talk further at police headquarters, according to the police report. There, he was formally charged but refused to speak further without an attorney present. He was given a ticket for city court and released.
    The officer noted in his report that Atkind acted "cocky and arrogant” and "made numerous comments that this incident meant nothing to him, that he would do it again, and that he knows how the criminal justice system works, and guaranteed me the prosecution of this case would result in an ACD in City Court.” The reference is to an "adjournment in contemplation of dismissal,” in which a judge typically tells a defendant to stay out of trouble for a period of time and the case will be dismissed.
    The case drew the attention of the Tompkins County SPCA, which sent out a press release saying that, according to a 1997 study done by the Massachusetts SPCA and Northeastern University, animal abusers are five times more likely to commit violent crimes against people and four times more likely to commit property crimes than individuals without a history of animal abuse.
    Princess is recovering, and has been treated at the veterinary hospital, according to Tompkins County SPCA Executive Director Abigail Smith. She was heading home with her owner Thursday afternoon, Smith said.
    Originally published March 16, 2007
    • Gold Top Dog
    That is so sad. I will never ever understand why someone would do that. That poor dog must have been in so much pain. Did the dog live? I read it but was a bit confused at weather they had to put her to sleep
    • Gold Top Dog
    ORIGINAL: Raja19

    That is so sad. I will never ever understand why someone would do that. That poor dog must have been in so much pain. Did the dog live? I read it but was a bit confused at weather they had to put her to sleep

     
    I think that she's still alive.
    • Bronze
    What makes me mad is that the guy (Atkind) was probably right when he said his case would likely get dismissed.
     
    I don't understand how someone who could do such horrible things (will likely) receive a VERBAL reprimand. Especially when he's saying he doesn't care, that he'll do it again...why is it that he can go with just a slap on the wrist?
    • Gold Top Dog

    "Alexander H. Atkind, 23, of 710 Stewart Ave., Apt. 8 and of Lexington, Mass., was charged with "overdriving, torturing and injuring animals” in violation of a section of the state Agriculture and Markets law. The offense is a misdemeanor. He was released with a ticket to appear in Ithaca City Court on Wednesday, March 21." 
    http://www.topix.net/forum/city/belmont-ma/TDK411JK50F6JEV1M 

    Ok, folks, we can do something about this.  Let's write some emails NOW and make this political!!  Emails from New York state residents are especially important.  Include the name "Princess" in the subject. 
     
    ETA:  This email campaign is now over.

    Address them as follows (the email addresses are below):

    Dear Ithaca Major Carolyn K. Peterson, Tompkins County District Attorney Gwen Wilkinson, and the honorable members of the Common Council of Ithaca, New York

    Make your email very, very polite.  Note that these people can not make the judge do anything.  Spell-check and re-read your emails.
     
    Tell them how you feel about this incident.  Ask for their help in getting the maximum sentence.  Say "thank you".  Talk about upgrading the charge.   Discuss the risk that this person will be violent against people.  Include the quote above and highlight the date.  If you are from outside the US, let these folks know that!!  (Nothing like having international exposure.  Wink  )
     
    Email addresses:
    asherman@cityofithaca.org, distatty@tompkins-co.org, sseger@cityofithaca.org, mcoles@cityofithaca.org, jclairbo@cityofithaca.org, mberry@cityofithaca.org, mtomlan@cityofithaca.org, jzumoff@cityofithaca.org, dgelinas@cityofithaca.org, gtownsend@cityofithaca.org, rkorherr@cityofithaca.org, dcogan@cityofithaca.org

    Note:  You can just send one email.  Copy from "Email addresses" through the last address.  Plug that into the "To" section of an email and then delete the excess text.

    ETA:   I added the City Attorney to the salutation and as the second email above.   Then I added the Tompkins County District Attorney to the salutation and as the third email address.

    ETA:  Ithaca City Attorney Daniel Hoffman (dawnt@cityofithaca.org) said "Please be assured that your point has been clearly made; additional communications of the same type will only interfere with our ability to do our work."  I have removed him from the mailing list.
    • Silver
    That is terrible!! Poor dog! [:(]
     
    edit: I've just sent an email to everyone on that list you provided. Thanks for that! Hopefully we can have an impact!
    :-)Emily
    • Gold Top Dog
    I added the City Attorney to my last post on this thread.   If you have not yet done so, please send the email requested in that post.  This monster needs the maximum possible sentence!
    • Gold Top Dog
    I added the Tompkins County District Attorney to my first post on this thread.
    • Gold Top Dog
    I can't even believe this. Would an email from Canada help too?
    • Gold Top Dog
    Oh that unholy _ucker.  I'm po'd beyond belief and yeah, will be getting those emails out pronto.
    • Gold Top Dog
    Yes, an email from Canada would help!!  Having the eyes of the world on this incident will get the attention of the politicians.
     
    If New York state does not have a felony charge for this offense, that needs to change as soon as possible and that is the job of the politicians.
    • Gold Top Dog
    If a forum member has not posted for a while, it would be great for them to get an email or PM about this monster, so we can get as many emails as possible by 5pm Tuesday.  Volunteers?

    The guy goes to court sometime Wednesday.
    • Gold Top Dog
    Bump to the top.
    • Gold Top Dog
    This guy appears in court tomorrow!  If you haven't yet, please send an email today demanding the harshest possible punishment.  The next victim of this sadistic man could be a child!!!
    • Gold Top Dog
    I got a response from Ithaca City Attorney Daniel Hoffman.  It included

    However, for your information, this matter is being handled by the Tompkins County District Attorney's office, not by this office.  Also, determinations regarding guilt and sentencing are made by the involved court, not by the prosecutors. 
     
    In the past couple of days, this office has received dozens of email messages on this matter, most of them containing identical language, some originating from other communities and other states, indicating an orchestrated effort.  Please be assured that your point has been clearly made; additional communications of the same type will only interfere with our ability to do our work.

    We are being heard!!  I removed the City Attorney from the mailing list as requested. 
     
    However, his statement that "determinations regarding guilt and sentencing are made by the involved court, not by the prosecutors."  is rather silly.  It is the prosecutors that must put in the work to present enough evidence to convict.  It is the prosecutors that make sentencing recommendations to the court.