samshine
Posted : 1/23/2007 12:28:01 PM
Hi again Leroi,
Sorry you are getting a bad vibe about the dog world. Let me give you some of the positives.
I've met a lot of great people in dogs. In fact, most of my friends. I have friends that I see at training classes, and friends from further away that I usually see only at shows. When I did not have a dog to show and found myself attending shows just to watch, I realized that for me being involved in dogs is about 50% social activity.
I enjoy training and working with my dogs. I like that having goals gives me something to work for and deepens my relationship with my dogs. I enjoy the lifetime of learning that comes with having dogs as a hobby. Genetics, bloodlines, behavior, learning theory, veterinary issues, social development, how to present a dog, structure, movement, etc etc etc. Always room to grow.
As far as politics in dog shows, this is the cry of people who did not stick around long enough in dogs to truly understand. You have to understand that a dog show is about the opinion of one person on one day. Each judge is an individual, their values are unique. For one judge a great head and expression is what speaks to them. For another judge easy and balanced movement is more important. Yes, there is a written standard for each breed but it can be interpreted differently. At any given show, the dog that I would pick to win usually does not. Is that politics? No. It is because my values are different from the judge. 99% of the time the judge is truthfully picking what he sees to be the best dog. Sometimes we can understand what the judge was looking for. For example you can see that having a ton of coat is important to that judge. Sometimes it is hard to understand what they are looking for. Very occasionally you get a judge that is plain incompetent.
To enjoy conformation showing you really have to look at the big picture. A good dog properly presented will do their fair share of winning. Sometimes they will lose to a dog that
in your opinion is inferior. The judge had a different opinion.
In the classes and breed competition I truly believe that there is not much politics involved. Once you are regularly competing in the group and best in show rings things get more complicated. Then judges can be influenced by advertising, handlers, etc. I think it is subconscious on the judge's part but is somewhat of a factor. Still, success can be had without all that. My friend's bitch came into her own this year. After she won the breed's national specialty this September, that put her number one in breed points. She decided to try and hang onto that ranking through the end of the year. So she started campaigning her girl and going to shows every weekend. She won several best in shows and tons of group placements. No advertising, no professional handler. Just a very good dog in her prime wonderfully presented. (my friend is an awesome handler.) If she did not keep the #1 ranking she came within a hair's breadth