agilebasenji
Posted : 1/8/2007 11:51:27 AM
Agiliebasenji - that whole "aussie" debate going around has made me stop and think about competing in AKC events. It seems like even if you get an ILP you can still get challenged? Its all sour grapes if you ask me. I think I'll stick with USDAA
I think part of the problem in this particular case, at least as I understand it, is that the dog was competing in other venues as different breed. Either it's an Aussie (an AKC breed) or it's a North American Shepherd (? that may not be exactly right) and it's not an AKC breed. Is the Mini Aussie a different breed from the Aussie? I have no idea.
I do know of someone who has a Laekenois who ILP'd her dog as a malinois. (The dog was out of coat when she took the ILP pics.) Personally, I like the owner and the dog and everywhere else in the world all the Belgians are the same breed, but according to the AKC they are not. And she knows her dog is a Laekenois, but put it down as a Malinois, which _is_ falsifying paperwork. Just because you don't like the rules doesn't give you an okay to not follow them. Especially in the case of agility where there are a lot of other venues that are more welcoming.
When we were looking for our malinois, we specificly looked for a malinois that we would be able to ILP without any problem. If we could not have done that, we probably would have gone the breeder route.
(Aside: I think the Laekenois is now part of the Misc class or an FSS breed, but this was not the case at the time. And I haven't seen her in a while, so the whole think may be moot now anyway.)
The thing I like about the AKC is that it acknowledges (almost) everything my dogs do. My dogs are so much more than "just" an agility dog. Which, to me, is what a purebred dog
should be. An ideal dog should be able to get his CH and his field titles AND do agility. And rally. And obedience. And therapy work (which the AKC does not recognize).
But I do think a lot of that is going out the window as I see BC's getting smaller and smaller. And other breeds developing a distinct split between the conformation and the field type dogs. The attitude seems to be "who cares about the good of the breed as long as I can win." (Of course that attitude is found in the conformation ring too.)
And now I'd like to applogize to the OP for taking this thread off course. [&:]