Dog held Hostage by Vet

    • Gold Top Dog

    Dog held Hostage by Vet

    Man says Gwinnett vet is keeping his dog hostage
    Vet says owner must pay $974 or the pup will be sent to the pound


    The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
    Published on: 09/14/07

    Josh Gomez says his dog, Pilot, is being held "hostage" by a vet who may send the animal to his death if Gomez doesn't pay up.


    Josh Gomez/Handout
    Pilot, the dog.
     

    The vet, Garry Innocent, says Gomez needs to pay $974 —or else he'll send the black border collie puppy to the pound, where the dog could be put to sleep.

    If that happens, the vet says, it would be Gomez's fault.

    "He's being such a twit," Innocent said Friday. "He just needs to pay his bill."

    Gomez has gone to court to try to save his dog.

    He filed a lawsuit in Gwinnett Superior Court this week to block Innocent and PetFIRST Animal Hospital in Duluth from handing Pilot over to animal-control authorities. In the suit, Gomez says he paid the clinic an agreed-upon $1,125 fee to treat Pilot in August for a virus.

    Then the clinic tacked on additional charges that Gomez can't afford to pay, Gomez says.

    According to the lawsuit, Innocent and PetFIRST said "they intended to dispose of his pet up to and including euthanization," which the lawsuit calls "a fancy word for killing plaintiff's pet dog." Innocent disputes Gomez's claims. He said he never explicitly told Gomez that his dog might be euthanized Innocent also said that when Gomez brought Pilot to the clinic on Aug. 26, he told the dog's owner that it would cost at least $1,400 to treat the pet. But when Gomez returned several days later, the cost for boarding and treating Pilot had climbed to $1,640. The unpaid portion of the bill has since doubled because of the $27-a-day boarding cost, Innocent said.

    Pilot remains at the animal hospital Friday and is scheduled to go to an animal shelter on Tuesday, Innocent says.

    Under Georgia law, veterinarians can hold pets when owners don't pay their bills. If an owner doesn't settle up within 10 days of receiving a demand for payment, the animal is declared "abandoned." It can be sold, given away or sent to a shelter and euthanized.

    Innocent said thousands of Georgia pets abandoned at animal hospitals "get put to sleep because of owners like this jerk.

    "It is a carnage. While the law cracks down on Michael Vick for dog abuse, nothing gets done about Joe Schmo for this kind of abuse," Innocent said. "We don't want to put this dog to sleep."

    Gomez's lawyer, Ed McCrimmon, says the Georgia law is unconstitutional because it enables pet clinics to take people's property without due process.

    Scott Piper, a spokesman for the Georgia Veteriniary Medical Association, said having to dispose of abandoned animals causes great conflict for veterinarians.

    "There's an ethical issue. There's a moral issue," Piper said. "I can tell you most veterinarians are torn between having to run a practice and do what's right by the animal.

    "It's kind of something that human doctors don't have to deal with because everybody has insurance, and if they don't, the state takes care of them," said Piper. "That's not the case for animals."

    Gomez insists he loves his pet and would be devastated if Pilot was killed.

    "I just don't even want to think about that," he said. As an in-home music teacher, the 22-year-old says he doesn't make much money. Gomez said he's already run up a $400 charge on his girlfriend's credit card and used a $750 loan from his boss to pay the clinic.

    He says he won't give up on bringing Pilot home.

    "Some of my friends tell me it's just a dog," Gomez says, "and I say 'I love this puppy.'"

    • Gold Top Dog

    So what's preventing this guy from waiting until the dog is relinquished to the shelter and just adopting him from there?  I'm sure the adoption fees are way less than the $900 he owes right now.

     

     

    • Bronze

    I was just about to post this article, but you beat me to it, Bobsk8. Big Smile

    Here's a link to leave a comment about the story:

    http://www.ajc.com/metro/content/metro/gwinnett/stories/2007/09/14/doghostage_0915_web.html?cxntlid=homepage_tab_newstab?cxntlid=inform#comments

    There was a comment from someone who used to go to this vet and she said he double-charged her and used her credit card to order meds for his own supply...and then he threatened to have her arrested for non-payment of those fraudulent charges.  This vet is anything but innocent!!!

    • Gold Top Dog

    Perhaps I'm wrong, but wouldn't his bill from his lawyer end up being more than the vet bill, too?

    • Gold Top Dog

    I just saw this now and was thinking the same thing----I hate when people say "it's just a dog"!

    • Gold Top Dog

    I'm thinking that a vet that would do something like that should find another line of work. It's not like having the dog euthed would result in him getting his money.  If  you don't pay your music teacher, the lessons stop.  If you don't pay your own doctor, he doesn't have you killed.

    Joyce

    • Gold Top Dog

    Bobsk8
    "Some of my friends tell me it's just a dog," Gomez says, "and I say 'I love this puppy.'"

     

     

    I love that line. That's awful what the vet is doing, saying they will euth. the dog. I have never heard of a vet doing that before. 

    • Gold Top Dog

    He should sue the vet and spread the word about his practice. This is a vet that should not be in buisness IMO.

    • Gold Top Dog

     I feel for the vet. Vets don't work for free; they don't get free equipment, they don't have the services of technicians and caretakers out of charity and they are not obligated to treat your dog for free. The guy brought the dog for treatment, got an estimate, the final charges came over the estimate, he would not or could not pay, the dog remained at the vet's accruing boarding fees. 

    Obviously the vet's in the wrong!  Come on!

     
    It is the dog owner's obligation to pay his bills. If I were stuck in that situation, how could it become my vet's fault for trying to get paid. This guy has money to go to court but won't or can't borrow the money from friends to liberate his dog?

     Please.

     

    Paula

     

    • Gold Top Dog

    I understand the vet has to get paid but this guy has already given the vet 1150 dollars. It isn't like he said "No I won't pay you." Any vet that actually cares about the animal would take that kind of down payment and let the owner make the best payments they could afterwards until it's paid off. Not take that guys 1150 dollars and euth. the dog anyway. And the guy will STILL owe that money. Killing the dog won't solve anyone's problems and the owner will likely NOT pay the remaining balance if his dog is killed when he was putting forth his best efforts to pay the bill.

     

    *edit*read the numbers wrong, sorry! 

    • Gold Top Dog

    I see where both of these people are coming from.  The guy wants his dog and the vet wants his money.  I don't see why the vet won't set up payments.  My vet is a very caring man, I took a stray cat to the vet and told him that I was going to keep the cat.  He gave that cat "the works" Shots, blood tests, neutered, everything all in the same day.  Then the vet gave me a 25% discount all because I was saving this cats life!!  He preformed a surgery on my dad's old dog and she had a stroke during the surgery, the vet said that he didn't want us to give up due to money issues.  In the end, we had to put the dog to sleep(she was 14) but the vet only charged for the actual surgery, no boarding fees, no medicine fees, nothing.  The bill was supposed to be well over $600 but he only charged $280.  My vet is not in the business just to make money, he actually cares about the animals. 

    • Gold Top Dog

    I can see both sides and it is very sad. However, a vet clinic is a business, like any other. If I took my car in for repairs, and only paid a portion of the bill, I wouldn't receive my car until the entire bill was paid. People seem to assume that since it is a vet, they should operate differently.

    Most vets do not WANT to put animals to sleep needlessly, so I wonder if this owner is using that as a pity plea. .

    • Gold Top Dog

    But even my doctor's will allow me to make payments to them if the bills are high and insurance won't cover it all.  I get to go home though.  It's not like they lock me up till I pay!  And my vet's office would certainly allow payment plans given a deposit of some kind, not make me accrue more by holding my dog in their care until it's all paid off.  It's ridiculous on the vet's side!

    • Gold Top Dog

    Of course the vet has to make money, but I don't think killing the patient is going to help him reach that end. If I owed my vet money, I sure as hell-o wouldn't make any attempt to pay him if he killed my dog over it.  How about taking the owner to court and having a judge set up a payment schedule? Or saving himself a lot of hassle and setting up a payment schedule himself?

    Joyce

    • Silver

    The vets in my area will not let you make payment plans. I was at the vet one day when a woman came in with a dog that got hit by a car and she was turned away. To be honest maybe she had a bad history with that vet I really don't know, but I felt sick watching her walk out the door holding her dog.

    I can see not having payment plans for routine visits, but I really wish there were payment plans for big bills, even if some interest were charged.