dogslyfe
Posted : 5/24/2006 9:05:09 AM
It's a sad thing. Will always fight to NOT let the E.S. become AKC. Makes me shudder.
AMEN. Unfortunately the working registries don't hold the same clout and financial power that a large organization such as the AKC does. Makes it very difficult for the small guys to win.
I wasn't involved in Border Collies when the AKC decided to recognize them, but by and large the working BC people fought hand, tooth, and nail trying to avoid that very thing. We still are very much fighting it! It has been very bad for the breed, and the conformation breeding of BC's (as someone else has mentioned) has evolved into a branch of dogs that are very little like the actual Border Collie. The very good news is that there still is quite the standing of working folk that continue to breed true to the working Border Collie. It really upsets me to see what breeding for a certain "look" has done for many of the breeds that USED TO BE working dogs. They have lost all but the barest instinct to work, and we are fighting hard to NEVER see that happen to the Border Collie. The BCish dogs they are putting up in the shows bear little resemblance to actual Border Collies, and many of us hope for a breed split. I think last statistic I saw, though, was something like 95% of BC's are registered with the ABCA, leaving a very small # of AKC reg'd Border Collies.
Actually its not completely the organization itself that I oppose, it is the conformation breeding and showing of working dogs (any working dogs for that matter, although the BC is near and dear to my heart). I personally couldn't care less how my BC looks. I DO however care about her livestock working ability, and her working heritage. The reason why this matters is this. When you SELECTIVELY breed for certain traits, then by and large it is those certain traits that you get. When one SELECTIVELY breeds for a certain look, what happens to that dog's working ability?? Bye bye. If you selectively breed for livestock working ability, then that is what you stand the best chance of getting.
Sad thing is that so MANY of the breeds originally had a working purpose, and all but handfulls who retained their abilities now have no original instinct/ability left. Very very sad.
Like Mudpuppy, I also disagree with what's happening health-wise in these breedings, even with the non-working bred breeds of dogs.
*shudders*