Xeph
Posted : 7/7/2006 5:49:15 PM
ORIGINAL: LizzieCollie
I believe one of my first posts on this forum was on this topic. Alot of people seem to think that because a dog is not shown in a conformation ring that it makes the breeder a BYB. I strongly disagree here. Collies, Cockers, GSD's, Goldens etc. were not bred to run in circles in a show ring. They were meant to hunt, herd, protect etc. If you have working stoc and breed your dogs it doesnt make you a BYB for breeding dogs so that they can do what they were meant to do. Just my thoughts
You're right, a collie doesn't herd on it's hair, but you keep obsessing about the fact that your dog doesn't have as full a coat as other collies. Well gee, it's because she's not from showlines!
And believe me, a Ch in front of a dog's name doesn't mean quality to me. I'd rather breed to a dog that has MACH 3 OTCH HT PT TC TT UDX MXJ
than a dog that is BIS BISS Am/Can/Int'l/Mex/Bra Ch.
Performance work is extremely important to maintain a breed, but what you're not getting is that your dog doesn't have a poofy coat and isn't a ball of fluff, because it's from working lines! Breeders of working lines don't see the need for all the coat, showline breeders do.
Lizzie's a nice little girl, but a show coat she will never have. If you're offended, fine, be offended. I had no idea what your location was until you PMed me. Puerto Rican working lines look almost exactly like American BYB/Pet lines.
My Strauss comes from Showlines (German) that are VERY well known for having thick plushy coats! Guess what? Strauss has the hair type of a
working line dog! Drives me absolutely batty, I wanted a nice thick haired plush dog, like my veteran, Ranger (he oozes coat!), but Strauss's coat is what it is.
He doesn't have all the coat I want, no, but holy CRAP he is an AWESOME working dog! Agility, tracking, schutzhund, herding, obedience, rally....there isn't much this dog DOESN'T do! He doesn't herd on his teeth or run agility on his hair follicles, but I would like more coat.