brookcove
Posted : 5/21/2007 2:01:04 PM
Mixed breed versus purebred: Any pup is a pig in a poke when it comes to really strict requirements. And much of your dog's personality and potential depends on training, which is up to you, no matter where you get a dog. Going the purebred route, assuming you select an excellent, responsible breeder, does give you the advantage of a mentor who can help you with any issues, advise you on training methods, and just generally be there for you as a first time dog owner. Most superior purebred rescues are the same - they are eager to share their knowlege of the breed with you and want to keep in touch with how their former foster dogs are doing. Purebreds from responsible breeders are just slightly more predictable in nature - however, most of the issues you bring up are just "dog" issues and can't be weeded out completely by selecting the right breed.
Small children in the home: I strongly advise one of two courses of action here. Either wait until the child is a good bit older and then work closely with an excellent breeder. Or work with a purebred rescue that fosters dogs in real home situations and evaluates them throughly for their reactions to children and numerous other things - small animals, other pets, strangers, riding in the car - the list goes on and on. In fact, this is the best way to get what you are looking for - adult dogs that are fostered in homes that are experienced with the breed and dogs in general. These rescues can match you with the dog that's right for your home environment - making it less of a guessing game or a "wait and see - and hope for the best" approach like it would be for a puppy.
Off leash: Some of these dogs would indeed be inappropriate to allow off leash for various safety reasons. My mom's landlady, who lives next door to them, has a Vizsla who she lets walk off leash to their car, for rides. She takes this dog on huge long walks multiple times, every day, so the dog is not underexercised. But if he sees a critter, he's gone, and he's not coming back until critter is a) inaccessible or b) dead. Training helps with some of this, but you really have to get the advice of experts in the breed you are considering. Or adopt an adult dog who has already shown trustworthiness off leash - whether that dog is a mixed breed or a purebred.
So the key is not adopting a
purebred, but adopting an adult dog whose personality is thoroughly known to the extent that you need it. Remember the vast majority of adult dogs end up in rescue through no fault of their own - most of them were simply discarded by owners who were bored with them, or got frustrated with some basic quality of doggishness like shedding, bringing in dirt, or barking - or just not being a cute puppy anymore.