Eric Mies
Posted : 10/4/2006 12:50:25 PM
It looks like we have done the same research alisia. I think it is kind of like crate training to a certain point - i.e. varying opinions. In any case, what I have decided (not a vet, just a conclusion I came to based of my research) is that soup bones (i.e. - femur and knuckle) bought at the grocery store are the best as they are the most natural. You just have to make sure there not small enough for the dog to try and swallow - not a problem for me as the average knuckle bone is the size of my dogs head.
Anyway, as for the ones you get at a pet store, first, you'll notice they are VERY white - that's cause they have been bleached and god knows what else. I did get one of these for my dog stuffed with peanut butter tho - I just found one that said natural, blah blah blah. Probably more to make me happy then the dog but what ever. In short, I will try to stay away from them but for this time that she is chewing anything and everything, since I wont let her have the knuckle in our room (carpet) it's either this or the crate at night. I will limit how many and often she gets them and once the stuff is gone inside, I will get all natural peanut butter at the store and stuff it myself.
As for Chicken vs. pork vs. lamb vs. what ever - chicken wings, drums, etc are going to be more fragile - there smaller, that simple. Because of this I wont give mine Chicken bones - some do and as I posted previously I read dogs can digest them easily enough - I'm more worried about them choking. I believe it was Glenmar who posted she feeds hers chicken bones and seems (to me anyway) to be pretty on the ball so hopefully she will be back to share her wisdom. [

]
As for raw vs. cooked - I think this was the one thing I found that FAR out weighed the other - raw is not only better, but cooked is dangerous. How ever, I do know people that boil them for about 2-3 minutes to "kill the germs". I personally don't feel this is necessary as the dogs digestive system is much stronger then ours (much higher level of acids and what not - hence being able to brake down bone) so I think they are really just making themselves feel better but I also don't think it is making the bones brittle since it's souch a short time either so, if it makes them feel good, so be it.
As for unsupervised - well this again, is very much opinion - TO A POINT. Take my dog (please! no J/K - bad Rodney Daingerfield reference) for instance, I give her a knuckle bone. Now that bone is roughly the same size as her head, and I think there is about as much chance of her braking off a piece of it and choking as there is of George Michael doing a come back tour - but I don't leave her in the crate with it alone either. I'll be the first to admit I'm probably overly cautious as some may be able to tell from my post's, but again, rather err on the side of caution.
I do how ever let her be in the kitchen alone with it - I'm 15 feet away and even though I can't see her, if she started choking I would hear it so...
Well that's my 2 cents - actually from the length of the post it's probably more like ten, if it were worth anything! [

] Anyway, hope it helps...