New dog while having problems with another?

    • Gold Top Dog
    If I may answer your question with a question....espencer, say you have a baby and it has a problem, like Down's Syndrome, just for an example.  Is it fair for people to criticize you if you should ever decide to have another baby?  A family dog?  A cat?  Because then you'd have to give attention to something else for a change....

    Personally, I don't feel that people have a given about a love and it is divided up.  No, I believe that people have the same capacity to love every person and every animal.  When I got married, it didn't mean I loved my cats less.  When I got another cat, it didn't mean I loved my husband less.  I think the same is true for devotion and commitment.  Love, devotion, and commitment are not always functions of time and space, IMO.
    • Gold Top Dog
    Lets say that is not a pet but a working dog, how do you train him to do what you want, how o you teach him that he can attack coyotes but not you? you need time to teach him that


    You really don't. Pyrenees at least were, and still are, bred for the purpose of guarding flocks. It's genetic for them. Most of them need VERY little direction as to what to do.

    Generally, when a LG puppy is being trained, it is penned with a lamb/kid whatever of similar size and pretty much left alone with it. Once it has bonded to that kid/lamb, it is slooowly introduced to the rest of the flock. Generally you'll want to pen up the puppy somewhere near the rest of the flock where they can see each other but not really interact. The rest of the flock, seeing that the kid/lamb that the puppy was raised with is not afraid of him and actively wants to be around him, will become curious and slightly less afraid of the scary predator in their midst.

    After a length of time when they have acclimated to him, it's safe to allow supervised interaction. The puppy, being bonded to goats/sheep will; not try to hurt the flock, but the flock may still be a bit wary and could injure a young puppy by butting/trampling him. So you'll want to supervise for a while, penning the puppy up near the flock when you're not around. Once the flock gets to the point that they are no longer defensive in any way towards the puppy, it's safe to leave them alone together. The dog will learn learn the boundaries of it's territory and will run the fence line periodically, barking the whole time, to ward off predators. This is something that they simply DO, not something that must be trained into them. In general, this is a big enough deterrant that nothing would dare come on the property. If something DID come on the property, it would have a 100+ pound angry dog to deal with. Though they bond mainly to the sheep/goats, they protect poultry by not allowing predators on the property in the first place. In general, the dog itself ignores poultry as long as it has been acclimated to chickens and such being present from an early age.

    So you see, there is really very little training other than very basic "leave it, come, etc." If you're saying that the 5-10 minutes of daily training it takes to do that takes too much time away from the problematic dog, well, then I respectfully disagree with you. That 5 minutes or so will not be missed.

    Training a LG is not like training a herding dog- in that not much formal training has to be done. If you have a decently bred puppy out of working lines, he should do the majority of this stuff on his own, with little direction from you.

    **content removed. off topic**
    Reminder: This is a theoretical discussion about the risks of adding a new dog to a household with an existing dog problem. It is not, and will not be personal.
    • Gold Top Dog
    Ratsicles, I am asking this in a most friendly and neutral way....ok[;)]

    **Content removed. Personal information.**
    • Gold Top Dog
    That proves my point, you have to do all that BESIDES help and aggressive dog BESIDES a new puppy

     
    Well...I got a completely opposite point out of the same comment by sillysally so I guess it's a matter of perspective and what you already have decided in your mind...you being general.
    • Gold Top Dog
    ORIGINAL: Dog_ma

    What constitutes "aggressive"?  

     
    That was going to be my question.  There are all forms of aggression.  My dog is a resource guarder and I have been working with him since he was 10 months old, he is now 2.5 years old.  I have learned to train and manage him very well, but he will always have some level of aggression in those circumstances i'm afraid.  I have another dog and they can get along just fine - even with food for the most part.  
     
    I wouldn't hesitate to get a puppy (if I wanted one, and I don't [;)]) just because River can be a little guardy.  I would just work around it and manage it.
     
    If I had a dog who was looking to tear off someones face everytime you turn around, I wouldn't even want pet snake nonetheless a another big responsibility like a puppy.
    • Gold Top Dog
    **Content removed. Refers to deleted material.**
    • Gold Top Dog
    If I may answer your question with a question....espencer, say you have a baby and it has a problem, like Down's Syndrome, just for an example. Is it fair for people to criticize you if you should ever decide to have another baby? A family dog? A cat? Because then you'd have to give attention to something else for a change....


    wow, great post. I think you hit the nail on the head.
    • Gold Top Dog
    Sorry for being off topic......DPU you must clean out your pm box, I can't reply, it says storage full[;)]
     
    I would not be able to rescue dogs if it wasn't for the facilities I have, if there wasn't a way of separating dogs in the beginning stages, I wouldn't rescue, simple as that......if I ended up with an aggressive dog I seriously doubt I would add on to an existing situation that needed extra work and care.
    • Gold Top Dog
    I believe situations like this usually fall into the "agree to disagree" realm.  It's all opinion-based and not everyone will have the same feelings about certain things.  That doesn't mean that one person's methods are any better than the other, just that different people handle situations in a different manner.  People are people, and they're all different...simple as that [:)]
    • Gold Top Dog
    **Content removed. Personal, off-topic**
    • Gold Top Dog
    This is the third and last reminder:

    This is a theoretical discussion about the risks of adding a new dog to a household with an existing dog problem. It is not, and will not be personal.

    Next inappropriate response buys this thread a time-out.


    • Gold Top Dog
    ORIGINAL: snownose

    Sorry for being off topic......DPU you must clean out your pm box, I can't reply, it says storage full[;)]

    I would not be able to rescue dogs if it wasn't for the facilities I have, if there wasn't a way of separating dogs in the beginning stages, I wouldn't rescue, simple as that......if I ended up with an aggressive dog I seriously doubt I would add on to an existing situation that needed extra work and care.


    Sorry for also going off-topic.  Snownose, PM box is clear but I had to get rid of some real juicey PMs.

    If the last foster had aggressive tendencies I would work with that dog before bringing in another.  My pack is solid and would work cohesively countering the aggressive one but a new one would not have the security of the pack and would be very vulnerable by the aggressive one.  Unnecessary stress for all of us.
    • Gold Top Dog
    ORIGINAL: espencer

    Would you get a new dog while you are having problems with one you already have and that is aggressive?

    It does not matter if they are 100 miles apart, a new dog is a big responsability even more if you already have a problematic one at home already, would you be whilling to take away some of the time that you need to help to rehabilitate your dog to train your new one?

    Or should you wait to help your current dog before getting the new one? 

    ETA: the new dog is a puppy


    Believe it or not espencer, I agree 100% with you in this matter. 
    • Gold Top Dog
    Thanks Ed [;)]

    ORIGINAL: Liesje

    If I may answer your question with a question....espencer, say you have a baby and it has a problem, like Down's Syndrome, just for an example.  Is it fair for people to criticize you if you should ever decide to have another baby?  A family dog?  A cat?  Because then you'd have to give attention to something else for a change....



    It does not apply, you cant "cure" Down's Syndrome, therefore you dont have the same options, lets say you cant cure either an agressive dog and he will be aggressive forever regardless what you do, would you still get another dog?

    You can NOT compare not having another dog to not having another baby, tooooootally different

    Now lets say you can "cure" Down's Syndrome, would you help your first child first before getting a new baby, or would you get a new baby while you are trying to "rehabilitate" the first one?

    Which one has better odds to be more succesfull?
    • Gold Top Dog
    quote:

    ORIGINAL: Liesje

    If I may answer your question with a question....espencer, say you have a baby and it has a problem, like Down's Syndrome, just for an example. Is it fair for people to criticize you if you should ever decide to have another baby? A family dog? A cat? Because then you'd have to give attention to something else for a change....



    Apples and oranges......I don't think a child with a disability would pose a danger as much as an aggressive dog would.