calliecritturs
Posted : 4/6/2007 7:15:13 PM
I don't leave my dogs uncrated. Period. Not at all.
I'm not hard or harsh -- I just plain don't want THEM getting hurt. Beyond destruction, it comes down to what they can ingest (it could have been something poisonous, not mink oil - it could have been carpet EATEN that could have caused an obstruction or a television pulled off or something that could have hurt the dog)
When it comes down to it -- it's not that the dog is unhappy - it's that human idea of ours that they need "freedom". But for a dog, that often translates to going space crazy. They are DEN animals. Small enclosed places make them feel safe. It's the place to sleep -- and if the dog gets adequate exercise and play time elsewise that's what they need. Not more 'freedom'.
Freedom can take on a tinge of panic -- they start doing something and begin to obsess over it (like the carpet). Just think for a moment how frantic the dog must have been digging to have accomplished that.
That's when freedom isn't kind honestly -- I've come home to enough messes to understand I'm not being as 'kind' as I thought I was. When I'm gone they sleep. I come home and I'm glad to see them and they're glad to see me. I take time to play with them and we're happy. I'm not having to deal with destruction (and have to deal with anger -- when they weren't even able to be scolded because how do you scold 'panic'??). Because there is no destruction when you crate.
If you are concerned about exercise -- you'd be better off to have a dog walker stop by and take them for exercise. But I've got enough experience with dogs that I've learned that they ALL get bored. They may be 'good' 99 days ... but all it takes is the wrong move on that 100th day -- getting tangled in a cord when they tried to cut thru behind the TV, or trying to find that one toast crumb behind something in the kitchen and they drag off some appliance and accidentally bonk themselves on the head.
All it takes is coming home to one disaster -- one hurt (or worse) dog -- and you wish you had left them crated.
I had a dog get mischevious ONE time -- he ate a 6' hole in a vellux blanket on the bed (he got up on the bed and just started chewing). He wasn't a chewer. But once he started he couldn't stop.
Vellux has nylon threads in it -- that could SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO easily have been a fatal obstruction. It could have tied itself around part of his intestine and he could have bled to death before I knew anything was wrong (waiting for him to poop out pieces). I could have lost him -- all because I was trying to be 'kind'.
It made me re-evaluate a crate.
Then -- just a couple of weeks later -- they ALL got into bird seed. Between 3 dogs they CONSUMED FIVE POUNDS of bird seed (cockatiel seed -- it was apparently yummy).
It could have made them deathly ill (it's not supposed to be consumed shells and all). Well it made them sick. I had poop from one end of the house to the other. Lordy what a mess.
And I had three sick dogs for days.
Yep -- crated now. And I don't feel bad at all. They're safe.