calliecritturs
Posted : 4/7/2013 3:14:55 PM
I'm going to third in the vote against a chain collar. They are supposed to train by sound not by jerking their neck -- but it's too easy to damage their throat and it is very difficult to do without it being really negative.
But bottom line -- there is no substitute for training **inside** first and then outside with a flat buckle collar and taking it a step at a time.
But that's not enough exercise -- for just "walking" on lead, you want to prevent them from successfully pulling as much as possible without hurting them. For a strong dog, I prefer a Sporn. Whichever style you choose, it tighens under the legs when they try to pull, and that tends to take the power out of the pull. But it won't come off (unless an Easy Walk is very carefully sized they CAN get out of them) and it won't hurt the neck/throat at all.
They look like torture when you open the box *grin* -- if you use the one with the collar you leave the collar quite roomy on the dog. Two straps attack at the bottom of the collar, go under the front legs and then attach to the back of the collar and up thru an adjustable slide. So when they pull, it pulls the collar DOWN, not up into the throat. The mesh style is even less constricting (and I really like those) -- you just slip the opening over the head and then slide the loops under each front leg and draw up the excess thru the slide. You do have to adjust the straps that go around the head/shoulders -- but there's a lot of freedom in how you make it fit. But they are nearly impossible for a dog to just slide out of.
This is the original sporn: http://sporn.com/training/sporn-halter/
This is the mesh one:
http://sporn.com/training/mesh-non-pull-harness/
you buy them by the size of the neck. My 19 pound pug requires the medium one (made almost as small as it will go - the Small is TOO small for that blocky pug head). Luna - who is 30 pounds but long and skinny -- I have her in the L/XL one made down as small as it will go, but it works perfectly (she's really strong but the straps are wider so I'm happy with it).
This is NOT a training collar -- this is to use when she's just on leash and we're "practicing" or when I just want to walk her and give her some room to relax.
Because of the bracheocephalic nature of the pug, she's in a harness most of the time but she's a soft dog so I use the sporn for training as well and it works because she's responsive.
Most trainers are going to want you to use a flat buckle collar and that's as it should be. But for the times you need to give them some room but you still want control? The sporn is great.