glenmar
Posted : 4/28/2008 8:20:33 AM
Janet Rose, thanks for posting the link for the dog food project. This is a wonderful resource and I hope that the OP will check it out.
Regarding SD, yes, I was just looking at the food this weekend. The puppy small bites, or whatever they call it, do not have meat. And yet the adult does. So SD figures that pups need a less stable protein source than adults???
Again, Mechanical, there are NO federal standards for by product. One batch could be mostly bone, which is going to mess up the calcium/phosperous ratio, the next could be mostly organ, which messes up something else. Dogs need an average of 5% of their daily diet to be organ meat, not a whole lot more or a whole lot less. If you happen to get several bags from the same production run and your dog is getting too much bone or too much organ meat it is NOT going to balance out over time. As gross as I find by product to be, IF there were federal standards, I might consider a food that had some by product in it. However, given that at the present time, by product is basically the tub where they toss the trash and then process it, ain't no way.
Same thing goes for animal or poultry fat. If you are using a food with "poultry fat", yeah, it's all birds. But, what KIND of bird? If your dog happens to be allergic to turkey, it's very difficult to figure out why ONE bag of food turns her fire engine red and the next doesn't. When a manufacturer uses a generic term such as this, it means that they have no standard for what sort of fat they use, and by gosh, whatever turns up in this particular bag is what they could get for the least amount of money at the time of the production run. Could be all chicken, all turkey, pheasant, duck, sparrow, whatever.
I won't say that vets get a cut of the proceeds on SD.....they probably do, just like PetsMart does when they sell anything. But, much of the training in nutritition DOES come from the big food companies.
What is your objection to training classes? I wonder if you have some misconceptions about them?