Aesop has always had gross poos, no matter the food. He's had fecal checks galore, we've tried different foods, and so on. To no avail. Finally I decided to, against my sadness, try Pro Plan Sensitive stomach formula. I'd heard others with dogs with touchy tummis had had good results. It did clear up his poo, however he only ate about 2 cups total in a week. He completely shunned the food when he'd see it in his bowl. He also pukes on an empty stomach, which added all sorts of new fun.
So, we decided to let him have his TOTW back and couple it with probiotics instead (he eats the fish formula...so it was odd that he'd not also eat the Pro Plan, which is salmon based...but alas). And oh, a happier dog you couldn't find. He kept looking at Ginger like "can you believe it's the good food?!" And he's been nearly cleaning his bowl each meal now, which is a new thing.
But, I'm not sure if it is the probiotics or what, but he's got completely normal stool now. Either way, we'll be staying with what works. (it is nice to have a happy dog too)