brookcove
Posted : 3/4/2009 3:13:36 PM
Well, really the problem isn't corn but the fact that cheap food usually substitutes some kind of vegetable gluten (corn is usually cheapest so it's most often used) for meat protein. There's been several studies showing that corn gluten is insufficient to maintain dogs in optimum health.
Here's one:
Statistical analysis revealed a moderate degree of correlation between
increasing quantities of corn gluten, which is low in essential amino
acids (i.e. lysine, tryptophan), and increasing loss of lean body mass
over the 10-week study (R = 0.56). Furthermore,
a moderate degree of correlation was observed between increasing
concentrations of corn gluten protein and decreased expression of the
p31 subunit of the 26S proteasome (R = 0.49).
Additionally, the dogs consuming the 12% protein diets had a
significant increase in fat mass regardless of the protein source.
These findings suggest that lean body wasting in adult canines can be
associated with the consumption of low protein diets consisting of
predominantly corn gluten, which is likely due to imbalances or
subclinical deficiencies of specific essential amino acids, and that
low protein diets may augment accumulation of adipose tissue. Although
the mechanisms remain unclear, alteration of molecular targets of
skeletal muscle proteolysis, specifically involving the UP pathway
occur.
http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/journal/118844846/abstract?CRETRY=1&SRETRY=0
Corn is not in and of itself evil. I don't like GMO corn but it's VERY hard to get away from. I don't think Eagle Pack uses it. As an energy source, it's actually (ironically) one of the less objectionable grains - lower in gluten and easy to digest, and it's so high energy that a corn-based carb formula can use LESS of the grain to achieve the same level of nutrition. Ie, I can feed less corn to my sheep than a food that is blended, because something called the TDN is higher in the pure corn. In a dog food, that leaves room for more meat - yay!
Sadly, a lot of holistic companies have bowed to people's perception that "corn is bad."
Take the "children of Jerusalem" approach. Buy him a bag of feed, something you think he'd be able to get readily and be okay feeding - nothing scary like Origen. Try one of the Diamond Naturals formulas (there's no corn in them but the better thing is that they are simple, easy to find, and don't look fancy). Or, if he's a Costco member, Kirkland's formula rocks and is probably cheaper than anything out there barring grocery store brands and Ol' Roy. Heck, Purina One is better than most of those foods - yeah, it's got corn but see above and it's not too dependent on gluten. But, Purina One is really pricey, ironically, compared to Diamond and Kirkland.
Ask him to give it a whirl for the whole bag. Challenge him to take a good picture of his dog before, smell his breath, look at his teeth, feel the handle of the coat. Then again after two weeks. Then, at the end of the bag.
Sidenote: The children of Jerusalem reference is from the Bible. You know Daniel and the lion's den? That same fella was captured when Jerusalem was conquered by Babylon. He and his friends were noble teenagers, ie, members of the royal household. Thus, they were incorporated into the king of Babylon's household to be trained as governors, accountants, etc. They were placed in a boarding school with a common eating area. They were, of course, Jews and the food was not kosher. They refused to eat.
The guy in charge started to sweat. His head was literally on the line if any of his charges got sick or even looked less than amazingly well-fed. He would be under suspicion of siphoning off the good stuff for his own use! So he begged them to eat.
Daniel had an idea. He said, "Give us just ten days. Let us eat only vegetables and drink only water. If you don't like the way we look after ten days, you can drag us to the king and let him execute us or send us to hard labor."
The vegetarians in our midst will not be surprised to hear that Daniel and his friends not only were in rosy good health at the end of the ten days, but they had also visibly gained more muscle weight and strength compared to their comrades who partook of the delicacies that were sent them from the king's kitchen.