Roxie865
Posted : 8/20/2006 9:36:21 PM
After Roxie began refusing Chicken Soup, I switched her to Nutro (only because she had loved a sample pack before ...). So ... she had been eating Nutro Natural Choice Large Breed Puppy and doing very well. Similar stools, similar feeding guidelines, blah, blah, and ... blah. I did hate the fact that I was paying the same for Nutro that I paid for CS, but there was nothing I could do -- she just would not touch the CS with a ten-foot pole.
I tried Canidae. B-O-M-B (my kitten also hated Felidae, by the way). Darn. She hated it more than the CS, I think. Eagle Pack didn't have much success, either, except for the nasty fish formula (and I'm sure everyone has read why I loathed that crap).
Now I'm feeding her Nutro Ultra Large Breed Puppy. Yeah, yeah, yeah ... I know ... it's not the greatest food in the world, especially compared to the amazing Innova. But guess what? I tried Innova before the Ultra. Same results as Canidae and CS. She obviously likes Nutro, it works well with her, and that is what we're sticking with for the time being. At this point, I'm so sick of food changes that I don't think I'll mess with it for a very long time.
So ... to sum up a post of rambling idiocy, I don't think Nutro is horrible if a dog does well on it. Mine does. Ron's does. Others do.