High Protein and Senoirs

    • Gold Top Dog

    High Protein and Senoirs

    I am so confused now.  I just got back from the vet, she told me that high protein food is not good for senoir dogs, it can cause kidney and liver failure.  Pella is 10 yrs old, she has always had a problem with leaking since very young. (I believe it had to do with when she was spayed.) So she has been on treatment for it ever since. Proin and just recently I have lower her Proin dose and have been giving her leaks no more instead.

    Now the vet is telling me her leaking could be caused as a side effect of the high protein food she is eating.  She told me as dogs age, you need to reduce their protein intake, because it is very hard on the internal organs.  And it can cause the kidneys to over work, which will cause more leaking.

    I don't know what to do, we are doing a urine sample on Monday. But do I keep her on the Fromm, she can not eat chicken  and I do not know of a senoir food that does not contain some type of chicken or grain. Ugh!  I am worried.

    Thanks for listening. 

     

    • Gold Top Dog
    goatman68
    I don't know what to do, we are doing a urine sample on Monday. But do I keep her on the Fromm, she can not eat chicken  and I do not know of a senoir food that does not contain some type of chicken or grain. Ugh!  I am worried.

    My old lady did fine on Natural Balance's LID line. IIRC, the protein levels are moderate (I'd venture to say 'low', especially in the duck and potato) and they are grain free.

    • Gold Top Dog

    High protein does not cause kidney and/or liver failure.  There is some thought that too much protein can potentially harm the kidney and liver if the one or each of the organs is already malfunctioning in some way.  With kidney disease, the factor to watch is phosphorus intake.

    Also, it has been recently discovered that seniors need a moderate (not low) amount of protein to prevent muscle wasting. (somewhere in the neighborhood of 25-28% protein on a dry matter basis)

    Some articles to consider:

    http://www.dogaware.com/articles/wdjseniordiets.html

    http://www.dogfoodproject.com/index.php?page=feeding_senior_dogs

    http://www.b-naturals.com/newsletter/is-it-necessary-to-reduce-protein-in-the-diet/

    But, if you are not comfortable with feeding a food with those levels of protein, you can always try one the Natural Balance Limited Ingredient Diets--most are grain free, and do not contain chicken.

    • Gold Top Dog

     I didn't think older dogs needed a Senior food? I thought an ALS food was fine for them. Could be wrong here, stranger things have happened. Smile

    • Gold Top Dog

    You are correct----that is the point behind all of the aforementioned articles.  Most ALS foods have a moderate amount of protein (24-28%).  Many senior dogs are less active, so it may be important to watch their fat intake.

    • Gold Top Dog

     Yeah me! I finally got something right.

    • Gold Top Dog

    Thank you guys for your replys, i am taking a urine sample in Monday, to make sure everything is ok there.

    Our vet is odd, she doesn't like anyone doing things out of her norm, like using food she does not sell. And I think she may be off with the food causing a problem, but the test will tell us.  I am just worried about Pella now, she is my babe and I want to make sure things are ok with her. She seems like her normal self, so I can't just blow off everything the vet says.

    I think I may go back to Natural Balance, and take a look at it again, I had tried it once awhile back.

    Anyway, thanks.

    • Gold Top Dog

    tzu_mom

    High protein does not cause kidney and/or liver failure.  There is some thought that too much protein can potentially harm the kidney and liver if the one or each of the organs is already malfunctioning in some way.  With kidney disease, the factor to watch is phosphorus intake.

    Also, it has been recently discovered that seniors need a moderate (not low) amount of protein to prevent muscle wasting. (somewhere in the neighborhood of 25-28% protein on a dry matter basis)

     

        Purina did a study that showed senior dogs on a lower protein diet did not live as long as those on a higher protein diet. I can't remember the exact amounts of protein they used, but Purina senior foods are 26 to 28% protein depending on the line. Royal Canin did a similar study. I have learned from working with Monica Segal on a diet for Jessie, who will soon be twelve, that dogs need at least 1 gram of protein per pound of body weight or they will have muscle wasting. The type of protein is important too; the first ingredient in the food should be a meat meal.  Foods with corn as the main protein source will cause muscle wasting, even if the total amount of protein is adequate, because corn lacks some of the amino acids needed to support muscle tissue. I add some lean turkey to Jessie's food (she can't have chicken either) to ensure she gets enough protein.

    • Gold Top Dog

    This get more interesting as I get more information.  The food Pella is on now is 24% protein and the first ingredient is Salmon.  She is 10yrs old and weighs 73 lbs

    Can't wait to get her test results, then I can hopefully, not worry about it.

     

    Thanks