calliecritturs
Posted : 6/18/2009 8:53:31 PM
willowchow
I still cannot say enough about Denosyl and Marin.
Marin IS a really good product. It **IS** milk thistle -- it's simply milk thistle that has been ultra refined by a pharmaceutical process. Sort of "concentrated" in a way.
Denosyl is a supplement -- it's pretty much Sam-e. This will help explain it better: http://nutramaxanimalhealth.com/Products/liver-health-pet-supplements.aspx#SAMe
Where the silymarin/milk thistle/marin is a protectant, the sam-e is a detox for the most part. Now milk thistle/silymarin/marin DOES detox to a degree, but if you want that serious "detox" you use the sam-e with it (and the Denosyl is formulated specifically to go WITH Marin).
The company that makes Marin and Denosyl is the same company that makes Adequan and Cosequin. It is a VERY reputable good quality product.
Now having said that -- there are specific reasons why I prefer the milk thistle as an herb, and I probably like Cell Food's Sam-e the best so far of the Sam-e's I've used.
Because marin is so processed -- yes, it is predictable. But it also carries with it the problems inherent in ANY pharmaceutical. It's not "natural" so it's not as easily "disposed" of by the body so you can't use large amounts of it. It's essentially a pharmaceutical version of milk thistle. So you gain the consistency and predictability you can get with a pharmaceutical but you *pay* in the fact that you can get harmful effects from "too much" (as in toxicity) that you aren't as likely to get with the natural herb.
My other reason is actually personal. As I said Marin is manufactured by the same company that does Adequan, etc. It is a very reputable, good quality company. BUT ... I don't like their way of testing their stuff. They have no problem inducing liver failure to TEST how their problem works on liver failure. IN other words, they don't go out and look for dogs in liver failure to try to "help". They will chemically induce a particular problem (to try to more tightly control that "control" group so all the animals have the same "level" of toxicity, etc. so they can "measure" it more closely).
I understand *why* they do it. But for me, personally, it is taking chemistry too far -- that's "animal testing" that I just plain can't condone. So I won't use their products.
I can't emphasize enough -- it is a very reputable company, and it IS an ***excellent*** product. But it's just not something I want to use when there is a natural available that I can use.
I really didn't know about Sam-e when I was dealing with Billy's stuff (I had to learn that to deal with Tink's and Billy's liver issues this past winter). If I had, I would have used Sam-e on Billy 3 years ago too probably.
The Cell Food Sam-e is pricey (ALL Sam-e is pricey -- I haven't found any of it that isn't). BUT it's a liquid!! Now this little bottle is $42.00 -- but it lasts a LONG time (like way over a month and I've been giving it heavily to two dogs -- like 10 drops to each dog twice a day). And I like Cell Food anyway -- it's a darned good supplement that *I* have used, so the fact that this has a bit of Cell Food in it suits me big time.
Bottom line I'm just trying to explain the Marin + Denosyl **pretty much equals** milk thistle + sam-e.