Why do people get judged when asking a breeding question????

    • Gold Top Dog

    samshine
    All puppies in a litter are the same age. The timing of the breedings matter only in that there be viable sperm present on the day the female is fertile. All the eggs produced ovulate on the same day. Then the eggs take three days to mature and be ready for fertilization. Then the eggs are only viable for one day. If there is sperm present at that time all the eggs will be fertilized pretty much on the same day.

    I stand corrected.  Thank you!

    This actually makes much more sense then the way I thought things worked.  I even found a site (Alabama A&M University) to back you up - with slight differences.  The site implies that the pups can vary in age by a few days - nothing like the drastic age differences that I thought could exist.

    Furthermore, it is during estrus that ovulation (release of eggs from ovarian follicles) takes place.  A surge in LH from the pituitary gland triggers ovulation, which occurs 1 to 3 days after LH [luteinizing hormone] levels peak in the bitch's bloodstream.  All mature ovarian follicles rupture and release their eggs into the oviducts within 24 to 48 hours.  Generally, larger dog breeds ovulate more eggs than smaller breeds.  Released eggs undergo maturation in 2 to 3 days and remain viable for a period of 12 to 72 hours.

    • Gold Top Dog

    Well, yes, but even a few days can make a huge difference is such a short gestation period.

    I used to breed.  My vet actually encouraged me to breed my cockers and then introduced me to another breeder.  That gal was a Godsend.  My vet didn't tell me about genetic testing, proving my dog, etc,etc, etc, but my mentor did.  She guided me step by step through the testing, she taught me things I never would have thought to ask.  Despite this, I would still have been considered a backyard breeder, although one of the better ones, because I didn't show.  The whole show circuit just leaves me cold.  But, I had AKC judges as friends through the breed club and I did have validation that my dogs were worthy of being bred.  My vet knew a good quality dog when he saw one, but he didn't give me much additional information.  I guess he wanted to leave all of that to my mentor.  And the whats in it for her answer was that she didn't want to see the breed destroyed, or downgraded.  And sadly, there are a whole heck of a lot of very poorly bred cockers that ruin the breed.

    I've even had an oppps litter or two.  On Sheba's first heat, Thor nailed her through the crate.  The result was two little pups who didn't live.  On her SECOND heat, my foster son let her out of TWO crates because she wanted to play with Thor.....this was in the time I was in the basement switching laundry for his infant sister from washer to dryer.......and yeah, they played.  The result was ONE pup, who is currently curled up at my feet.  There have been no more litters.  I did not intend to add a third german shepherd.  Nor did I intend to add numbers four, five or six.  They came from litters I fostered.

    So I've been there, done that and bought a tshirt along the way.  And yep, I'm still going to try to discourage folks from breeding willy nilly.  I'm not judging, and there have been many folks who've come to this forum who have found whelping a bit easier, because of people here.  The gal who was earlier referred to as a breeder....gosh guys, I beg to differ.  This is a high school kid who let two dogs of different sizes breed and doesn't think it's a big deal that daddy is four pounds bigger than momma.  If it were the other way around, not such a big deal, but, in this case, yep, I strongly suggested a spay/abort.  Trying to whelp those pups could very easily kill momma and the pups and sadly she hasn't been back to update us.

    I have long been active in rescue and fostering.  I work with two HS to help raise money to take care of the "throw away" animals.  My last pregnant momma who came to me to whelp was a "valuable show dog" yet when she got loose while her owners were vacationing, they spent no effort to find her......a year later they decided to start looking for her and the "valuable" pups.  She whelped nine pups.  One was stillborn, one died four days later, one collapsed and died at almost five months of a congenital heart issue, another had testicals that never dropped and is a royal pain in the fanny.  He was one of TWO runts.....the other is the boy who died at five months.....and both of them needed bottle feeding to supplement because they couldn't get enough milk from momma.  Yet another, at almost three, still is leggy as a youngster and hasn't even thought about filling out.......this "valuable show dog" should not have been bred, and I know from folks who know that daddy is another that should not have contributed genetic material to the cause.  He too is a "valuable show dog".

    I know what I'm doing and have whelped a lot of litters, my own and fosters, and to this day it scares the socks right off me when the time comes.  It is NOT easy, it isn't "fun".  It's one heck of a lot of hard work and heart ache, even when things go well.  And I am HORRIFIED when someone comes on here with a pregnant bitch needing such basic information as how long "it takes" before puppies arrive.  Breeding should NOT be taken lightly and as a right.  Most people don't pop out babies every nine or ten months because the can, and people who are responsible about breeding find these answers BEFORE the first sperm flies.  Not after.  They don't let their dogs breed on a whim and then expect strangers to make it easier for them.  I'm not a proponant of abortion, so by golly, it's an extreme circumstance that makes me suggest a spay/abort.

    But, I will always help people, regardless of how foolish I think they are being, simply because whats done is done and it's about keeping momma and the pups safe and alive.  But, yes, I will discourage any way I can, someone who wants to breed "just because", and if I'm not tactful about it, opps.  We all have our hot buttons, and the irresponsible breeding of dogs is one of mine.

    • Gold Top Dog

    Probably because most people that are asking these question are wanting to breed a byb/run of the mill dog. Most of those people don't even know what OFA, CERF, Pennhip or whatever breed specific tests that particular breed requires, are! Most of these people do not own a proven dog...as in shows, shutzhund, whatever. Just because a dog is registered with the AKC, does not mean it's a quality dog. I don't care how pretty it is, or how sweet, that doesn't mean anything.

    I am shocked at how many people have asked if i wanted to breed either of my dogs. First off, they are neutered, but my response is always, "My dogs are not breeding quality, sorry."

    That being said, i am totally for a responsible, quality breeder. I have contacted a breeder for a puppy i will get next year. The parents are health AND temperament tested, some are CGC and therapy dogs, some compete in schutzhund and the others are ch in the show ring.

    • Gold Top Dog

    RidgebackGermansShep
    I am shocked at how many people have asked if i wanted to breed either of my dogs. First off, they are neutered, but my response is always, "My dogs are not breeding quality, sorry."

    Idea  A neutered, but still interested male might be just what their breeding program needs.  Stick out tongue 

    Note:  That was a joke, folks.  I am not suggesting that anyone actually do that.

    • Gold Top Dog

    I am going to add my 2 cents in here.

    First off, there is no such thing as a dumb question. Secondly, while there are many seach engines to find information on breeding, breeds and training, some people choose "gasp" a dog forum, imagine that.

    There are many people on this board who are very tenacious in certain area's, and they come off strong or judgemental, even though they really are not or don't intend to be. By the same token, this board at times is easy to read, and trolls come along and post questions they know are going to get someone on a tangent and make tempers flare.

    As for breeding, unless your dog is a proven winner and has something to contribute to the breed standard and is not going to be bred to a dog of the same breed with the same standards, forget it, they should not be bred, period.

    • Gold Top Dog

    Truley

    As for breeding, unless your dog is a proven winner and has something to contribute to the breed standard and is not going to be bred to a dog of the same breed with the same standards, forget it, they should not be bred, period.

    Proven winner in whose eyes?  When it comes to "contribute to the breed standard" isn't that just personal preferences....color, etc.  Its just a continuation of what the one considers a great dog, a personal judgement.  There is a "responsible" breeder in Michigan breeding Great Danes, smaller size, longer necks. 

    The simple answer to the OP question is that the "people" have an elitist attitude, one of the 7 deadly sins.  Those that breed as a hobby, good for them.  For those that want a one time experience or a continuation of what they consider a great dog, good for them too.

    • Gold Top Dog

    I'll be darned if I have an elitest attitude.  But, by golly, I've seen many breeds changed and ruined by irresponsible breeding.  And YOUR attitude that it's all good is what contributes to you and I needing to foster, what contributes to the pet over population.

    I could CLONE a dog and still not end up with the same critter.  Life experience contributes a great deal to who and what anyone, dog included, evenutally is.

    • Gold Top Dog

    DPU

    Truley

    As for breeding, unless your dog is a proven winner and has something to contribute to the breed standard and is not going to be bred to a dog of the same breed with the same standards, forget it, they should not be bred, period.

    Proven winner in whose eyes?  When it comes to "contribute to the breed standard" isn't that just personal preferences....color, etc.  Its just a continuation of what the one considers a great dog, a personal judgement.  There is a "responsible" breeder in Michigan breeding Great Danes, smaller size, longer necks. 

    The simple answer to the OP question is that the "people" have an elitist attitude, one of the 7 deadly sins.  Those that breed as a hobby, good for them.  For those that want a one time experience or a continuation of what they consider a great dog, good for them too.

     

    Good grief.  This is the attitude that is causing the problems.  You really ARE JQP aren't you?  I really thought that the long standing memebrs of this forum were longer sighted and better informed than this.

    • Gold Top Dog

    I don't have an elitist attitude, far from it. But unless you breeding something "bad" out to put something "better" in, why should you breed?

    I have a neighbor who has a chi, and her brother has a fox terrier. Just pets, but they plan to breed them, why you ask? Well because when they were kids there favorite dog was a mix of the 2, oh yes, that is a good reason to breed.

    Or, how about my other neighbor, they went to the HS to get a puppy, but did not, why? cause the husband did not think they had the right to "fix" his dog, what if they wanted to have puppies? They have a dog they got a flea market, and you know what, it is alone 80% of the day, stays in a crate in the house overnight, out in bad weather, they spend no training or quaility time with it.

    I cannot support that kind of breeding. The problem is everyone is in love with puppies, but forget they grow up and lose those puppy ways.

     

    • Gold Top Dog

    DPU
    Proven winner in whose eyes?  When it comes to "contribute to the breed standard" isn't that just personal preferences....color, etc.  Its just a continuation of what the one considers a great dog, a personal judgement.  There is a "responsible" breeder in Michigan breeding Great Danes, smaller size, longer necks. 

     

    Good point.....I love white GSDs,I have owned one in the past and one day I will own another one....... as we all know they are not breed standard.

    edit due to big fat typo....lol

    • Gold Top Dog

    Truley

    I don't have an elitist attitude, far from it.

    Sure you do because the extent of your involvement with the two live example you provided is to make a condescending assumptions and judgements.  If you were really true to your cause you would be more involved, even to the point actually helping them and educating them along the way.  I think the experience of having your favorites dogs mate is very aluring but after one experience, it does not always lead to a 2nd experience.   

    If you can't support that kind of breeding, then YOU don't do it. 

    • Gold Top Dog

    snownose

    Good point.....I love white GSDs,I have owned one in the passed and one day I will own another one....... as we all know they are not breed standard.

    My sister has a pack of White GSDs, wonderful dogs. 

    Did you know that Drizzle (in my sig) is highly prized for breeding because she is harlequin and she has a white chest, at least that is what I was told.  Now, what is that??????????  Rather than breed to make a difference in things that count, like a stronger heart in GD, they chose to breed for a white chest or cosmetics.

    • Gold Top Dog

    snownose

    Good point.....I love white GSDs,I have owned one in the past and one day I will own another one....... as we all know they are not breed standard.

     

    But they have their own parent club with their own standard, they are their own variety in the UKC ring, they can compete in AKC events and Schutzhund, so it's very possible for them to be tested against the standard, either the GSD standard or their own.  SchH was designed specifically to test GSDs, and you can compete in SchH with a mutt.

    • Gold Top Dog

    DPU

     

    Did you know that Drizzle (in my sig) is highly prized for breeding because she is harlequin and she has a white chest, at least that is what I was told.  Now, what is that??????????  Rather than breed to make a difference in things that count, like a stronger heart in GD, they chose to breed for a white chest or cosmetics.

     

    That sounds like an issue with that breed or that breeder.  It doesn't mean EVERYONE feels that way.  In GSDs, NO color or pattern is considered any more or less rare, or more or less desirable than any other.  Look at my Kenya, tons of people tell me my dog CANT be a German Shepherd b/c she's not black and tan, yet, she is a conformation champion!  The only split are the whites b/c they have their own parent club and standard  .  There are some really decent breeders of whites out there, really good people with great German Shepherds.  Other than that, anyone breeding for color is not considered reputable among the breed fanciers.  Some try to sell solid blacks or liver and tans as "rare", they don't care about German Shepherd dogs, they are just trying to make a buck.

    If the Great Dane standard favors one color over another, then that's something Great Dane people need to bring up to the parent club and change. 

    • Gold Top Dog

    Liesje

    If the Great Dane standard favors one color over another, then that's something Great Dane people need to bring up to the parent club and change. 

    Hee hee, I know you say one color over another, but look at what the standard is for a Harlequin Great Dane...so trivial.

    "The base color shall be pure white with black torn patches irregularly and well distributed over the entire body; a pure white neck is preferred.

    The black patches should never be large enough to give the appearance of a blanket,
    nor so small as to give a stippled or dappled effect.


    Eligible, but less desirable, are a few small gray patches
    (This gray is a Merle marking)
    or a white base with single black hairs
    showing through, which tend to give a salt and pepper or dirty effect.


    Any variance in color or markings described above
    shall be faulted to the extent of the deviation.
    A Great Dane which does not fall within the above color classifications must be disqualified."

    Quoted from the Great Dane Club of America's Website: