JoAnnDe
Posted : 6/3/2007 6:33:09 AM
You really can't truly 'mimic' a commercial diet -- because they put an unbelievable amount of 'supplementation' in their food (so the 'food' isn't always what you think it is).
I don't mean that particular one, I mean anything ... in other words if you are feeding XYZ's "duck and sweet potato" -- you can't just serve homecooked duck and sweet potato and have that be the 'same' as that commercial food. The commerical foods all have (at least the better quality ones) specific standards they have to meet with x% of calcium, y% of phosphorous, z% of Vit A, etc. -- so whatever those main ingredients don't have they add as supplementation.
I didn't mean that to be cryptic -- but she made the comment that she'd use turkey and something to be like a food she'd fed before. My caution was that you can't just use those named "things" and have a complete diet. I wasn't being negative about commercial diets -- just cautioning that she not try to have a couple of ingredients be a complete diet.
ORIGINAL: calliecritturs
Sorry - I didn't mean that I could COMPLETELY mimic the canned (why would I want to LOL). What I meant was that I'll start with the same primary ingredients (egg, turkey, rice), add my own supplements (which I have, since I was homecooking) and try to mimic the protein / fat / carb ratios at first.
I do understand about balancing the diet - I've read both of Monica's books, 5 of her pamplets, etc. It just seems that Prancer can't handle a high protein + high fat diet - one of those is throwing her system into a tizzy. Its either that or she's intolerant to some ingredient I was using. Since she pretty much had an iron stomach before this I was using ALOT of variety, giving a different recipe (diff protein and carb sources) every day. Alas, now I don't know which it is so I need to go very slowly next time around.
But I have to wonder .... the Hills I/D has 30% calories from fat and 22% calories from protein. The fat seems way high for a dog with pancreatitis yet many of them do well on it ... baffling. Hence my theory that its the combination of high fat / high protein that does it with Prancer.
My husband is DEAD SET against me homecooking now - I need to show him that ESPECIALLY NOW its better for Prancer.
Re Monica Segal - I do believe that I'll be asking her to review my recipes going forward. Don't tell my husband but I'm working on new spreadsheet right now LOL