Lynn
Posted : 12/31/2006 10:43:04 AM
Callie, I'm not terribly fond of basil, and only like pesto on sandwiches, but, gee, for you I'll look for some next week. [

]
Honestly, girl, I believe what you say about the basil, but you must be one-in-a-million,
Whoever breaks out in hives from a leaf of a herb???? How very odd that seems.
About the "allergy" definition; I dunno, it's not worth arguing over, but I'm going to continue the conversation anyway. And, I'm not trying to argue, btw.
My take on Callie's explanation (yes, it did make sense) was that if a dog had a severe reaction, then it's an allergy. If a dog's system is "bothered" in some way, then it's an intolerance.
That makes sense, but I still wouldn't know in what catagory to place my dog. We discovered she's allergic to brown rice. ARRRRGGGHHHHH. So, she takes in brown rice, and not immediately - not within minutes- but in a few hours starts itching and her skin does become red. She does have a reaction to it. The more she eats, the worse her symptoms get.
So, I think Callie would call that an "intolerance".
But, now lets also say that her poops following this are partly black, and take days to clear back up to all brown. Which indicates upper GI intestinal bleeding. Pretty bad gut inflammation. In this case senerio, would you still call it "intolerance".
I look at it a bit differently. If I give my dogs a top brand, higher protein diet and they have runny poops for one month straight - I call that "intolerance". My boy eats brussel sprouts (not again, if I can help it), and his gas could fuel a motor bike, then I call that "intolerance".
If the reaction is bad enough to migrate to the skin - in an attempt, perhaps, by her body to eliminate the problem??- and my girl is now red, or itching on her skin, then I think it's a bad enough reaction to her body to qualify as an allergen.
When you break out in hives from that dreaded Basil leaf - oh no [&o]- then you are having an allergic reaction. Right?
So, when my girl's skin turns red and itches (like in hives), then why wouldn't it also be considered an allergy
just because of the time difference. I'm not convinced that just because it shows up in your skin with 60 seconds makes it an allergen, but if it shows up a few hours later, then it's not?
I would call the first case scenerio a severe allegen, but still consider the second case an allergen since it still has the same basic outcome for the body.
[

]
Lynn