Sera_J
Posted : 4/29/2010 4:15:30 PM
First of all, I'm assuming we don't need to bring up PM/BYB's whose obvious goal is monetary gain. So with that in mind, I'm only addressing reputably bred dogs.
I think that "improving the breed" is subjective, which is why people breed. ... everyone's idea of "improvement" is different. Some think conformation, natural instinct (for their original use, in my case bird work) is more important, some for temperament, or health. I think some look at the whole package. Going with the whole package may be a "jack of all trades, master of none" kind of deal to others. So, everyone breeds for a different ideal therefore their idea of "improvement" is subjective.
So, your breeder wasn't as happy with the pups from her last litter so she's going elsewhere, that's IMO, being very honest. She's aiming for a high standard, based on conformation, and she didn't get it, she's able to admit she's not happy and try again. Right on! I've noticed a lot of people aren't able to be that honest with themselves, completely kennel blind. They bred it therefore it's perfect.
I own a stud-dog, as most of you know, and have co-bred a litter. The goal was to have happy, versatile pups. I want a dog that can win in the ring and then go out and hunt. I want a dog with a wonderful, biddable temperament, and healthy long-lived pups. My mentors are those who can scrutinize their own line, recognize their weakness (or plural!) and strive to improve it, to whatever their standard is. If someone is content in their breeding program, I don't think they are trying hard enough ;) LOL That's what I've learned. You can always improve, but you must be honest with yourself about what you have to do so.