Owners barking at provincial law banning pit bulls

    • Bronze

    Owners barking at provincial law banning pit bulls

    Ontario’s controversial ban on pit bulls — now five years old — is under fire once again as a coalition of dog-loving groups rallied yesterday to support a local MPP’s efforts to have the law changed.

    “They’re ripping family pets away from people based on very vague legislation,” said Rui Branco, who successfully fought the City of Brampton earlier this year by proving his dog, Brittany, was not a pit bull.

    The American bulldog-boxer mix was seized and held by the city for three months before an independent veterinarian was able to determine it was not a pit bull.

    “An animal control officer looked at her and said she was a pit bull. Then she was taken away from us.”

    A few hundred people and dozens of muzzled pit bull-type dogs gathered at Coronation Park to protest Ontario’s ban on pit bulls and to demand the repeal of “breed specific legislation.”

    The Dog Owner’s Liability Act was amended in 2005 to ban the breeding, sale and ownership of pit bulls. But since “pit bull” is not a specific breed of dog, the province’s definition includes pit bull terriers, Staffordshire bull terriers, American Staffordshire terriers, American pit bull terriers and any dog “that has an appearance and physical characteristics that are substantially similar” to those breeds, such as large heads, broad shoulders and muscular builds.

    http://www.metronews.ca/toronto/local/article/615310--owners-barking-at-provincial-law-banning-pit-bulls

     

    • Silver
    Sadly this was talked about having a law like this in Indianapolis, near where I live. The thought was people in bad neighborhoods owning pit bulls posed a danger to others. The law was opposed due to a) the question of what is a pit bull and b) the unfairness of assuming all pit bulls are a danger. If a dog is dangerous, then the government has the right to get involved, but this idea of just discrimination against pit bulls is ridiculous. I’ve heard somewhere that the dog who causes more problems for kids (as far as aggression) is the Dalmatian. No one would think that, right? I’ve never had a pit bull, but my aunt has one and she’s the sweetest dog and the biggest baby.

     

    • Puppy

     Oh, BSL makes me crazy. Leaving the aside the barely-concealed racist underpinnings, these laws exemplify the magical thinking of the prohibitionist mindset—that we can cure the degeneracy of a society by banning one of the symptoms. (Rather than, say, by enforcing existing laws—in this case, against dogfighting.) It just doesn't work. It's feel-good piffle for legislators. I can understand the desire to be seen as doing something about violent crime, but it's deeply unjust to penalize good citizens—be they human or canine—in the process.