DE-BUNK it. When next go go on your walk talk all excitedly about "Let's go see the Smith's new scarecrow!!! Is he still THERE? Let's go see -- it'll be FUN!"
Take treats you know are irresistible. FROM **YOUR** hand.
You see it and say with a big huge smile "WOW -- LOOKIT!! It's still there -- how KEWEL!!!"
Don't rush him, but keep your attitude light. You get there and say "Here -- what a good quiet boy!" and then step closer and say "Wow -- he doesn't move -- but his jacket flaps HERE (shove food in mouth)" but just walk slowly and get closer and encourage him to sniff and evaluate. YOU touch it and let him sniff and see what flaps, does it make noise, wassup????
You set the tone -- "Wow -- he looks scarey but he's not!" Offer a treat to the scarecrow -- nope, not gonna take it -- YOU have it!
Approach it happily but cautiously -- do this with anything 'new' and weird on walks.
It's a super good thing to seek out the weird and unusual -- Mrs. Schmuckatella hung out laundry and it's flapping and making noise? ASK HER if you can get just a bit closer so he can check it out.
But if you approach things and honestly appear interested yourself, the dog will trust your lead and you can de-bunk new things and build confidence in him at the same time.
David and I both love little animated toys -- and when a dog first comes to us they are always greeted with more than a little fear. But by de-bunking them and showing the dog what they do they become no problem.
I have a little dog on a rocking 'sled' -- and he plays "Jingle Bells". Long ago when we were going to get Tink and hadn't decided on a name yet I was talking about here on here. Then when we decided on the name "Tinkerbell" I commented that each of my dogs has their own "song" so I was gonna have to get Disney-fied and FIND a song for her.
Janet.Michel came up with singing "Tinkerbell" to "Jingle Bells". WHAT SHE STARTED!!!
Tinker-bell, Tinker-bell, Tinker ALL the Way!!!
Oh What fun it is to have PUGGY KISSES all tha DAyyyyyyy
Tinker-bell, Tinker-bell, Tinker ALL the Way!!!
Oh What fun it is to have PUGGY ...KISS-ESSSS all tha DA-a-a-a-a-a-a-ayyyyyyy" (big finish of course)
And of course I sing to the little rocking sled dog.
TINK THINKS THIS IS SOOOOOOOOOOOO KEWEL. See, everbuddy's got their own song -- but SHE has a TOY that knows HER SONG. It's too funny for words.
And yeah -- this was a dog who was terrified to walk past the cockatiel when she came home with us.
Our trainer will, during puppy classes, often bring out weird stuff as distractions. An open umbrella rolling on the ground, various weird toys, a cow in a homespun dress that covers her vacuum cleaner -- ANYTHING that flaps, flutters, makes noise or looks imposing.
But learning HOW to lead them on an investigation of a new thing opens all sorts of new doors for training.