Kim_MacMillan
Posted : 2/22/2008 5:57:53 PM
I may be one of the few here who feels differently, but I think her taking the dog to a shelter is a lot better than a lot of alternatives dogs face. Being left behind, being thrown out on to the street, being handed off to the first person who wants the dog (honestly, there are a lot of folks who would love to get their hands on PB's just for the image, that should be nowhere near dogs), etc. At least in a shelter the dog will be safe, cared for, and assessed. It's not ideal, and rescue would be better, but shelters are there for a reason, for people who simply shouldn't have dogs and need somewhere for the dogs to go. It's unfortunate that they always put down pit bulls, if that's the case that they do do that, but if we had to choose, I would opt for kind euthanasia over getting hit by a car, used in dog fighting, starving, or other such despicable actions.
On another note, not all no-kill shelters are created equal either, and there are a lot of reasons in which I do not like a lot of them. A dog living its life in a 6x6 (or smaller) cell is no "life" for a dog. Even if it gets one, maybe two walks per day, and one or two toys, and a pat here or there at meal times. In no kill shelters dogs can go what in the human world would be classified as clinically insane, where they start tail-chasing, flank suckign, staring at walls, chasing their own shadow, or simply become depressed and lonely. I think there are far worse things for a dog than kind euthanasia.
Now in saying that, I'm not saying there are no other options. You can try to help her rehome this dog, you can try to assist her in caring for the dog and teach her, you can try to help find people who may be interested, give her a list of organizations that take in dogs, maybe especially bullies......I just wanted to be clear that while a shelter is not the best solution, there is a reason we need shelters - because of people like this, who act as though dogs are expendable. And those dogs need somewhere to go, at least it's warm and has four walls and some meals and promise of water.