calliecritturs
Posted : 5/27/2006 5:54:46 PM
Essentially Heartguard is ivermectin -- but in order to make it 'safe' (which my personal opinion is that it is truly not 'safe' ever for herding breeds -- if it is a dog 'sensitive' to it, it WILL cross the semi-permeable brain membrane -- the dog just may not be able to TELL you how yucky it feels). But in order to make it theoretically 'safe' for ALL dogs they have reduced the dose so seriously that it's sometimes not even effective on microfilaria of heartworm. But it's defnitely not effective for any other blood parasite.
Interceptor, because it's safer for all breeds (there has been SOME problems but very few compared to the risk that the parasites bring) is dosed a bit higher, so it actually protects not just against heartworm but things like hooks and whips (not if you are reducing the dose tho, altho some of us do that).
I'm in Florida too -- I've seen what heartworm does to a dog, and I've also seen how horribly traumatic it is for a dog to be TREATED for heartworm. Heartworm is now in all 50 states, including Alaska and in Canada. I treat 12 months a year because it's an absolute must here.
There are some "natural" methods (and that is SUCH a 'loaded' word it's almost a glittering generality) -- but they all involve things like black walnut (which is a plant derivative) -- but that IS a poison. I know a lot of folks use these alternative methods but I won't/don't. For a couple of reasons:
1. I don't think they are AS safe as the Interceptor. All the 'herbals' used ARE toxic to a great degree and I think it's too hard to dose them safely. And what's the difference in giving an herbal 'poison' and giving a pharmaceutical one?
I use herbs ALL the time -- herbs, homeopathics, Chinese herbals, and other alternative 'stuff'. But I try to be really safe and really informed about them and I've never come to the conclusion *I* knew enough about these heartworm 'preventives' (NONE of which truly 'prevent' -- they simply kill microfilaria after the dog has been bitten by a heartworm-infected mosquito) to feel nearly as safe with them as I do with Interceptor.
2. With Interceptor it's been tested enough and has enoug longevity that we do at least know what organs it might be problematic to -- so I KNOW that after my dogs get Interceptor for a few days after I give them milk thistle so it helps detoxify the liver. I don't feel comfortable knowing what the danger points are with the various natural options out there.
I guess, bottom line, even as much as I *know* about herbals -- the herbal options scare me. A good friend of mine (actually a gal who occasionally posts here and often 'reads') tried one of these 'herbal' heartworm remedies and wound up in some real trouble with her dog. That's not the only time I've heard of it going awry. I think the size, metabolism and general health of the dog has an enormous amount to do with how 'well' they do on the herbal options.