brookcove
Posted : 4/13/2007 9:03:50 AM
Pulik are Hungarian all purpose herding dogs. Ie, yard dogs - get the cattle/goats/sheep/geese in, bark when intruders arrive, alert when something's wrong, and drive the animals to market and watch over them when they get there. They are family oriented but not terribly outgoing. They've got a ton of energy, being working dogs and not "improved" [8|] much to make them your standard American yard ornament type dog. The coat is VERY high-maintenence, unless you want a dog that is basically a walking filth mop. I think you can prevent the coat from cording and therefore end up with a very expensive, high energy, not very friendly poodle.
Komondorak are one of the fiercest of the livestock guardian breeds, also originating in Hungary. Like all guardian breeds they are a giant breed and must be socialized absolutely correctly within a short window, and in the case of the Komondor, even then you'll have a dog that is often dangerous to the unwary visitor.
This is not a breed for the faint-hearted and certainly not for someone looking for a low maintenance dog to scare away intruders. They were used over here for a while to increase aggression in some of our more mellow livestock guardian breeds (Pyrs and Maremmas), if that tells you anything. The Spanish Mastiff and Polish Tatra has since become more popular for that purpose, as the crosses produced therefrom are LESS of a liability if your farm has lots of human visitors. Again, if that tells you anything about the personality of the Komondor.
I've "met" a few from a distance and don't wish to get much closer. The corded coat is the same as the Puli - you can put a lot of time into it or keep it cut and end up with a huge, expensive, really people aggressive poodle. I don't know why you'd have a Komondor if you weren't gobsmacked with the breed and showed them or used them for livestock guarding (note, I don't think it's possible in this breed to excel in both, unlike with some other livestock guardian breeds).
The Bergamasco sounds like a neat alternative to these breeds - the temperament sounds similiar to the other Italian livestock guardian breed, the Maremma, my breed of choice here (dog pictured in sig line). And the coat is matted permanently rather than corded - not attractive to me, but they do say it's easy care after some initial setting up. I bet it's a pricey beast, though. [
]