FourIsCompany
Posted : 8/14/2007 10:25:39 AM
After thinking about the "which collar" question a while, I'm going to say that I would go with whichever one my dog responded to the best. Unfortunately, there's no way to know which that is without trying them.
mudpuppy makes a great point about the bark limiter collar. That might be worth trying.
And the shock delivered by a bark collar (especially if it's adjustable) would probably be effective, without "hurting" him (of course it hurts some, but without permanent damage). My neighbor's tiny chi-chi mix has an invisible fence and it works great for him, but I've heard him whimper as he gets close to the boundary... Perhaps it's just anxiety.
I think before I tried a collar, I'd get a doggie door that leads into a locked fence and give him a good walk in the morning with stuff to keep him occupied during the day. That's what we have here and I can't imagine any other set-up.
Just wanted to add those thoughts... Good luck! [

]