mudpuppy
Posted : 6/5/2006 3:04:20 PM
These are all just tools to help re-train a dog. If you start out from day one insisting upon no-pulling, you will need nothing to help you, you can walk your dog on a body harness or a flat buckle collar, or even off-leash.
I think prongs are the best choice for dogs who normally don't pull, but every now and again, for environmental reasons, lunge hard against the leash. The prong automatically punishes them for lunging.
For dogs who habitually just pull hard all the time, an easy walk harness may help you break the habit. But you have to work with the dog, not just assume the equipment will solve the problem.
I'm not willing to use a choker-- the only way to use a choker to teach loose-leash walking is if you plan to give the dog a leash-pop every time he ALMOST pulls. If you wait until he is pulling, you can't give a proper leash pop. Which means you're constantly punishing your dog for almost being bad. Not fair. Traditionally you'd use a choker NOT to teach loose-leash walking, but to teach the dog to walk in heel position, so he'd get leash-popped every time he moves out of heel position. I think expecting your dog to constantly heel on every single walk takes most of the fun out of it from your dog-- dogs get most of their jollies on walks by sniffing, which they can't do in heel position. Many a dog who can do a lovely heel on command will still pull hard on leash when not being asked to heel. Loose-leash walking is a different concept than heel.