Michelle Boyle
Posted : 7/19/2006 10:53:37 PM
Hmmm....those noise collars could potentially cause hearing damage, I think. Seems cruel to me. However, I think this is just one of those things that maybe should be taken on a dog by dog situation, if you know what I mean.
For instance, a skittish dog could freak out with a collar like this, but maybe another one wouldn't be bothered by one. We had a dog who responded really well to a very soft, firm, "Uh-uh." But, we have one now who barks until he's hoarse and completely ignores us when we give a command during this time. He is perfect in every other way and is actually quite submissive and wants to be very good, so its puzzling. The breath spray worked perfectly for him. Go figure.
I'd try a citronella collar before a sound one. You can get one with a remote and control. Then, you can use a control word and then hit the spray at the exact moment he barks. I think you may never need to actually leave the dog with it on because its the same aversion training as the spray (only I don't think your guy will be as enthused about this as the water spray!) The one bad thing I've heard about this is that the collars (any type) can go off with even a small noise or sometimes even a certain movement, like scratching, so who knows what the poor dog would be learning from the collar while you're not around. Personally, they're just not my cup of tea.