Animal Consciousness Article

    • Gold Top Dog

    Animal Consciousness Article

    Colin Allen studied philosophy, but his PhD work was very ethology focused, as are most of his current research activity.

     

    For Dog Forum folk who are interested in the subject, this article gives a history of how philosophers have dealt with animal consciousness over time.  It is long, but pretty readable.

     

    It still amuses me that, even after Temple Grandin explains how her autism allows her to think in images, modern ethologists still get hung up in the anthropocentric bias of 'How can animals think without language."  What the hell do they think dog barks, whines, bows, or dolphin clicks are about  for heaven's sake?

     

     [url]http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/consciousness-animal/[/url]

    • Gold Top Dog

    I haven't had a chance to read the entire article but I had to laugh a bit at this part, as it's so true.  Thanks for sharing.

     "The philosophical issues surrounding the interpretation of experiments to investigate perception, learning, categorization, memory, spatial cognition, numerosity, communication, language, social cognition, theory of mind, causal reasoning, and metacognition in animals are discussed in the entry on animal cognition. Despite all this work, the topic of consciousness per se in animals has remained controversial, even taboo, among scientists, even while it remains a matter of common sense to most people that many other animals do have conscious experiences."

     

    • Gold Top Dog

     Jackie

     Since I decided to leave a tenured position in academia as a professor of civil engineering, convinced of the superiority of spending quality time with my dogs (and not w/ colleagues and administrators), I have spent the past 7 years revisiting the field of my avocation I discovered as an undergraduate - philosophy.

     

    Well, after engaging with these type of folk on various web forums, I think they are more than overrated, they are, by and large, insecure and vindictive.

     

    I find more pleasure in watching Peanut sashay by, tail held high and showing her butt.

     

    It's of Nature, I think, that we owe our fascination.

     


     

    • Gold Top Dog

     Just saw a 2012 PBS Nature show (long) on whale and dolphin intelligence, self-awareness, innate empathy, inter-species and extra-species communication.  Just amazing!

    • Gold Top Dog

     Mommas don't let your babies grow up to read humanities...let 'em study beagles, and bovines, and such... http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/03/science/animal-studies-move-from-the-lab-to-the-lecture-hall.html?_r=1

    • Gold Top Dog

     

    'bout time!  ^