This really got on my nerves.

These are the same so-called experts who know everything...about nothing at all.  Just ignore them.

Gypsy had accidents off and on until she was about four months old. I would say this is more common than being trained at just a few weeks!

lorib

These are the same so-called experts who know everything...about nothing at all.  Just ignore them.

Yep.  Both Nikon and Pan took a while (and I took them out every 10-15 minutes while awake, but their bladders are so "young" that when they have to go they just GO, there's no holding it or warning system until they are older).  I'd say at about 4 months it was like a lightbulb went off, and they went from having multiple accidents a day to nothing.  Occasionally there would be an accident but from 4 months on it was my fault.  Pan had two accidents at our new house (6 months).

Wouldn't it have been perfect if Royce had peed in one of those "experts" shoes?    Maybe they would have left early.

I agree that people like those aren't worth arguing with.  I've housetrained lots of puppies and adult dogs and there's no timeline that fits all.  You're doing fine and so is Royce. 

Kash is 3.5 months now and his schedule is now quite predictable - if mom and dad are supervising!! If not, and he needs to go? Well, he'll go. And I wouldn't blame him!  The biggest one for us is catching him as soon as he's done eating, as he poops right after he eats (not that typical "20-30 minutes after as is often quoted). But it's so easy to just want to stir the supper pot, or put the dishes in the dishwasher, or water that plant by the sink, and then realize that you are 0.004 seconds too late. *G* Housetraining is truly about training the people, the dogs are always happy to go along!

Accidents are bound to happen, and while some can claim errorless housetraining, I say don't sweat it. Royce will get there when his body and maturity are ready!

It took us almost a year before Sadie was 100% - I think that was a combination of us being first time dog owners, her being a beagle, her hating rain, whatever. With Timmy - it was MUCH quicker, I forget exactly when he was 100% but it was fast - whether that was due to having Sadie to follow, us knowing more of what to do, I have no idea. My point is, every dog will be different - you are doing a great job with Royce :)

lorib

These are the same so-called experts who know everything...about nothing at all.  Just ignore them.

Typically these same people ALSO have children who were potty trained by age 1...that now do not speak to them or treat them like doo doo...and also have spouses that do whatever they tell them to...and are on spouse #2-6.

Make like a duck and let the water roll off.

(((HUGS))) to everyone. Thank you. It was so nice to see I'm not an enabler who just doesn't know how to train a puppy to respect me and the house, lol. Fact: These relatives feed their dog Ol' Roy. Need I say more about how highly qualified they are? I just don't believe in throwing a fit for housetraining accidents because it isn't his fault, and if it's ANYONES fault, it would be mine. I will make sure I put my own face near the accident and yell at myself,

Truth is I love 'em and they really do love dogs, they're just... old school.

 Beejou, your always so positive and willing to listen to the negative comments. You actually listen to both sides and then make your decision. Unlike me who flies off the handle at every little thing.

Your a great mom to Royce and T-Bone and they're lucky to have you.

Aww, thank you Tiffy :) I just figure even if I don't like what is being said, someone is taking the time to share with me because they're passionate and everyone knows /something/. That and I don't want people to feel unappreciated or unwelcomed by me, I would be hurt if someone just told me to shut it, LoL!

BTW, Tootsie is lucky to have you too :) Your devotion to her is lovely to see.

 Ahhh, your to sweet!