NUTRO food contamination

    • Gold Top Dog
    Many dogs did get sick or die before it came out about Diamond dog food.  Many dogs did get sick or die before it came out about Proheart6,  Many people did have strokes, heart attacks or die before it came out about Vioxx and Phen-fen.
     
    It is a shame it has come to this, people fearful of giving their dogs store bought food, treats, etc.  But if there is any doubt, I think care is in order.  It is a catch 22.  You hate to stop feeding you dog a certain food because of something like this that has not been proven, yet on the other hand, you would hate to use it and have your dog become sick, or worse, die.  Then you are blaming yourself for not listening to the warning.  I do not use that brand so I am lucky I do not have to make any kind of decision about stopping or continueing using it.
     
    And personally, if there is any doubt about any product i feed my dogs or myself, I sure want to know about it.  I didn't find out about Proheart6 until my Hunter I had died, and I didn't find out about Vioxx, which I had been on, until there were lots of cases of stroke, heart attack and death brought out.
    • Gold Top Dog
    I used to feed Nutro. It was better than Eukanuba that made my dog go bald.  But then I found out it had BHT in it so I swtiched to California Natural.  Now she is on raw.  But it could be too late because she was just diagnosed with a tumor on her heart and and enlarged heart and arrythmea.
    • Bronze
    OMG!!  I used to feed that to my dog!  From the way the company reacted, it sounds like they were already aware of a problem with the food!
    • Gold Top Dog
    weren't dogs dying for months before people realized it was contaminated Diamond dog food at fault? 

     
    I think it got recalled right away,,,but it didn't get to the public that fast, blaming on the Christmas holidays!   
    I think we should beware, but not panic!  Wait and see!
    • Gold Top Dog
    That is what bothered me.  The fact they told her they needed 4 cups, but then asked for it all, and how fast they were wanting to compensate her, which i would bet my last dollar it meant her signing a release saying she wouldn't talk about it any more to anyone.
     
    Right after Hunter died oct. 16, 2003, I wrote Fort Dodge and told them their ProHeart6 had killed him.    No reply.   As I learned of more stuff, like their dear doctor letter (at the FDA's "request") saying AIHA was one of the adverse rections, I wrote.  No reply.  As dog deaths were mounting up and more came out, like the Dear Doctor Letter writtn to vets listing death as an of the reactions( this was written the day Hunter got his fatal injection, and again as at the FDA "request").  I was writing them every 2 weeks or so with more information.  I didnt hear a word from them UNTIL for some unknown reason I sent a copy of my $2300 vet bill. this was in late Feb. I think.  I got a letter that they sometimes helped people with unusual high bills, and were willing to pay the $1049.71 diagnositc part of the bill.  That sounded good until I read on down the letter and saw about signing the release.  That realease would have shut me up.  I would not be able to reveal any "data, information, discovery," with "any person or entity under any circumstance."
    Need i say I refused.  As far as I was concerned they could put the money and the release where the sun didn't shine.  No way was i going to close my mouth if i could save one dog for the suffering Hunter and so many otherrs went thru and one person from the grief so many of us had.
     
    I was able to have the tee shirt below made and on the back with same wording is a picture of a border collie mix who died in Wis. the same day my Hunter died here (had his owners permission).  I wore it all the time and carried flyers i made up to hand out of anyone asked me about it--and they did.  I visited forums and told the story, hubby put up flyers in truck stops, handed them out to other drivers that had dogs in their rigs etc.  We will never know if we saved a life or not, but we did the best we could
     
    Meanwhile, I learn about the FDA hand delivered warning letter to the Fort dodge animal meds plant--un sanitary conditions, workers not dressed properly, air being allowed to flow from one contained area to another contained area, etc etc.  As it goes on it talks about other problems, like the recall of EtoGesic because of the pills not being up to standard.  it so happens my KayCee had been on that following knee surgery just before the recall and I still had the bottle.  Then I find out some batches of ProHeart6 had been recalled because of trouble with the time release spheres not working properly.  I do not know if they were not releasing when they should, were all releasing at the same or whatever.
     
    Armed with all this I wrote Fort Dodge again and in about 10 days, they paid the $1049.71 and sent a "generous donation to Texas A&M Vet School in Hunter's memory and I DIDN'T HAVE TO SIGN A RELEASE. Maybe they thought i would drop out of sight, but i couldn't.
     
    My point is, ProHeart 6 was killing dogs and they knew it, but they offer to compensate the biggest majority of the people and the ones they did offer, they wanted a signed release to shut them up.  This is why I was wondering why this company was so quick to offer compensation  Of course it could be they do not think their food is at fault and don't want word to spread like it did with Diamond--even tho Diamond was bad.  Whatever, an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.
     

    • Gold Top Dog
    That is what bothered me.  The fact they told her they needed 4 cups, but then asked for it all, and how fast they were wanting to compensate her, which i would bet my last dollar it meant her signing a release saying she wouldn't talk about it any more to anyone.

     
    Boy I agree on that Sandra.  But I also want to believe that if they really felt there was a problem with that lot number on the food, or any of their food at all, that they would put out a warning immediately!  Diamond has to be loosing tons of money on what happened to them. I bet there are many many people that will never go back to their food again. I believe these companies would cover up to save their companies, but they can't cover up the fact that dogs are dying,,, as Diamond couldn't. It would be better for them in the long run to put a warning out right away and not loose any more dogs.
    I hope to heck  that food companies are a whole lot more caring and responsible then Ft. Dodge/Wyeth and probably other drug companies.
    • Gold Top Dog
    Someone from another list called them, this is the result of that phone call.
    Julie
     
    I know that there is a lot of concern out there regarding the Nutro
    scare.  There is also a great deal of confusion regarding whether it's
    Nutro or Nutra, whether it's a possible contamination or a full-blown
    recall, etc.  So I took it upon myself to call Nutro (yes, it's Nutro
    with an "o" - not Nutra with an "a") at 800-833-5330 and ask.  Here's
    what they said:

    There was an incident in Texas 2 weeks ago, where a consumer's dogs
    became ill.  Samples of the product were sent to Nutro by the consumer
    so the food can be tested.  The sample food was received April 7th and
    is currently being processed.  The results of the processing will
    probably be available in May.  So far, this is an isolated incident –
    there have been no other complaints.
    • Gold Top Dog
    Do you mean NATURA?  As in Innova and EVO?
    • Gold Top Dog
    NO it is definately N U T R O
     
    Has nothing to do with Natura.
     
     
    • Gold Top Dog
    Not sure, but MSU could be Michigan State University.. we have a huge vet school and labratories here.
     
    When one of our horses went down when I was a kid and the local vet couldn't figure it out, we loaded her in the trailer and took her to MSU.. with almost no clues what to start looking for, they were able to pinpoint a weed that grew along our creek that adult horses know enough to leave alone, but babies don't. It caused nerve damage and she couldn't walk anymore and we had to put her down.
     
    Sorry to hear about Gunner. My thoughts are with his mom and family.
    • Gold Top Dog
    My question was by nutra did the poster mean Natura?  If not, I've not heard of nutra so it peaked my curiosity....
    • Gold Top Dog
    The first post says "Nutru Natrual Choice Lamb & Rice Formula"  so Im sure they were talking about Nutro and just acciently put a u at the end.  And they went as far as to name the bag, which Nutro does have.
     
    Edited for spelling as is always the case w me.
    • Gold Top Dog
    Thanks for the claification.
    • Gold Top Dog
    ORIGINAL: brookcove

    I assumed MSU was the closest vet school.  Like I lived in NC, the western past, for 15 years but my necropsies would have gone to VTI in VA, only ninety min away, versus NC State three hours away.  Isn't MSU in Miss?

     
    I'm in grad school at Mississippi State, and yes, we have a vet school...pass in front of it everyday. If this occurred in TX, there's at least one vet school closer (LSU), at least to the east of TX anyway.
    • Gold Top Dog
    I am guessing MSU is Michigan State, I believe they have the National Food Safety and Toxicology Center.