Roxie865
Posted : 9/21/2006 12:55:18 AM
I'm glad I'm not the only who has been through a huge variety of dog (and cat) foods!
When Roxie first showed up at my house, I went to Wal-Mart and bought her a bag of Puppy Chow. At the time, I had no clue how lousy it was for her. She did like it, of course. My last dog had done very well on Pedigree, so I ended up switching her to its puppy formula. She didn't like it, though. I eventually began researching dog stuff and came across this board. That changed things for me. I began feeding a better food at that point. Anyway, I'll just list and describe each food. It's a long list ...
Puppy Chow - She liked its taste and had normal stools.
Pedigree Puppy - This one didn't go so well, with loose stools and little interest in the kibble.
Chicken Soup for the Large Breed Puppy's Soul - She was on this food for a while, and her coat really improved tenfold. Her stools were fine and she loved it. Well, she loved it for a while and suddenly stopped liking it.
Nutro Natural Choice Large Breed Puppy - Yeah, I went downhill in quality, but I hadn't gone to a feed store yet. She liked this food more than CS. Stools were fine and her coat improved quite a bit.
Eagle Pack Holistic: Fish & Duck Formulas - She hated the duck and refused to eat it; she LOVED the revolting fish forumla and wanted more of it. That crap made me want to vomit, as I hate fish. Its smell was absolutely hideous, and she smelled like rotten fish after eating it. Never again.
Canidae - She was not crazy about this. I liked its ingredients, but it wasn't appealing. Her stools were fine.
Nutro Ultra Large Breed Puppy - Of all the foods we've tried, this was her absolute favorite, even over the EP Fish crap. Her coat was great, the stools great, but it was overpriced and used corn gluten meal as its third ingredient. Ridiculous.
Innova Large Breed Puppy - Huge kibble size in comparison to other foods she had eaten, though she hated it anyway. Well, she did at first. For some reason she began to eat it after I'd decided to return the unused portion. Big mistake. She had explosive diarrhea. After that, she didn't want to eat it again, either.
Solid Gold Wolf Cub - She refused to eat it.
California Natural Puppy: Chicken and Rice - She did extremely well on this one. Her stools were the best they'd ever been and she genuinedly liked it.
Timberwolf Organics: Dakota Bison - She wasn't impressed and wouldn't eat much of it. Too bad, because I like its ingredients.
Healthwise Puppy: Chicken Meal and Brown Rice - This is what she's eating NOW. Overall, I think it's the best match for her. She has no problem with chicken, she really likes its taste, and her stools are fine.
As for canned foods, I cannot remember what all she has tried. So many.
Trixie (the kitten) has eaten Nutro (I knew about pet food by this time) most of her life. I tried Felidae and Innova, but she hated them. And the Felidae gave her bad diarrhea. She also turned down CA Natural's cat formula, so I tried Healthwise Cat 'n' Kitten. She actually LOVES it; go figure.
Both of my girls are doing very well on Healthwise. That's what we're sticking with.