What do you think of this dog food??

    • Gold Top Dog

    What do you think of this dog food??

     It's called Purina One Beyond and here are the ingredients;

    Salmon, chicken meal, whole brown rice, soybean meal, whole barley, whole oat meal, animal fat preserved with mixed-tocopherols (form of Vitamin E), soy protein isolate, brewers dried yeast, dried egg product, dried beet pulp, natural flavor, fish oil, phosphoric acid, calcium carbonate, whole cranberries, caramel color, dried tomatoes, dried spinach, salt, potassium chloride, taurine, choline chloride, calcium phosphate, Vitamin E supplement, zinc sulfate, ferrous sulfate, niacin, manganese sulfate, Vitamin A supplement, calcium pantothenate, thiamine mononitrate, copper sulfate, riboflavin supplement, Vitamin B-12 supplement, pyridoxine hydrochloride, folic acid, Vitamin D-3 supplement, calcium iodate, biotin, menadione sodium bisulfite complex (source of Vitamin K activity), sodium selenite.

    • Gold Top Dog

    Salmon as the first ingredient is misleading since it's basically chicken.  I avoid corn, wheat soy, grain glutens and grain fragments.  No from me.  Sorry.  My crew have been eating Taste of the Wild and do very well on it.  For Health is a less costly brand by the same manufacturer, but good ingredients.  I am not a big fan of Diamond who makes both of these foods, but, I've gotta say that these two are outstanding.  I *think* that For Health is exclusive to Tractor Supply.

    Oh, and I prefer a NAMED animal fat....this leaves  it wide open and they can use whatever they feel like tossing into the mix and some dogs may have sensitivities to some proteins/fats.

    • Gold Top Dog

     Our problem is.....when we got Ruby her owners were feeding her Purina Healthy Morsels.....we were going to get some to help transition her over to something a lot better. Well in our stores we couldn't find it so we bought a small bag of Purina One Beyond.....well I noticed with it that Ruby has bad gas so we bought some Natures Balance........she won't eat the Natures Balance.....even bought a different flavor of it because that's what I've read but she won't eat that either. She will eat the Purina One Beyond. The problem is I know it's not the best food for her and would love to switch to something better but can't afford to keep buying bags of food for her to try and not like.

    Any suggestions?

    • Gold Top Dog
    my small dogs are on taste of the wild. the female had BAD gas before she was on that...

    my aussie looked great on it, but grain free did not agree with him... and he lost a lot of weight. Ive got him back on Blue Buffalo, and he's doing great.

    I don't have a lot of patience with my dogs... either they eat what's in their bowl, or they don't eat at all. no healthy dog is going to starve themselves.

    that said - many companies will send you sample bags of food if you request them!
    • Gold Top Dog

    erica1989

    that said - many companies will send you sample bags of food if you request them!

     

     You beat me to it, Erica! All the pet stores I've gone to, excluding Petco or Petsmart, always have samples of different dog foods.

    • Gold Top Dog

     Thank you all for your opinions and your advice. I found a link where you can get free samples of dog food mailed to you.........just pay shipping and handling. So we are going to try that.

    • Gold Top Dog

    Ummmm, that link might be a scam.  Maybe not, but just check it out carefully.

    I'm going to agree that a healthy dog will not starve him/herself.  In our house, bowls are on the floor for a max of 15 minutes.  House rule.  However, in reality, the bowls are empty in far less time.  But, the point being, here is you food....eat it or loose it and you wont' get anything else until your next regular feeding time.  I wouldn't feed my human kids ice cream for every meal just because they'll eat it.....why do the equivilent with my dogs?

    • Gold Top Dog
    k9cuisine.com will send you free samples if you pay S&H, I think :)

    Anyway, we have the 15 minute rule here too, but I do try to stay away from plain kibbles. If I have to feed dry food (rarely) I add a little "something" like yogurt or pumpkin or canned food and some warm water to spice it up. The trick is that YOU decide what goes in the bowl before it hits the floor.

    • Gold Top Dog

     That's the site I am talking about..........glad someone else knows about it. I think what some of our issue here is this............the people that we got her from fed her human food.........we don't do that here. So I think she is going to be stubborn about this issue. If I put down what I want her to eat and she don't eat............how long do I let her go without eating............meaning days?

    • Gold Top Dog
    I live in a little beachy town, so there aren't many options here for quality dog food :) I almost always order online.

    Now, see, my dogs often get human food in their bowls. In fact, their particular brand, The Honest Kitchen, is made from all human-grade ingredients. There's nothing wrong with giving dogs something that you'd eat - in fact, it happens all the time here, especially if I make too much for my hubs and I. However, we generally eat healthy things like lean cuts of meat and veggies. Pirate LOVES steamed asparagus :)

    BUT with that said, we go back to one of my main rules of life...you get what you get, and you don't throw a fit. What's in your bowl is what's in there and you aren't getting something else. Sometimes, though, if you've got a particularly bright dog, you've got to stack the odds in your favor. Make it something they WANT to eat. For Pirate, it had to become a habit to clean his bowl - so I had to start with putting REALLY YUMMY STUFF in there. Now it's a habit for him to clean his bowl - I could throw a bowl of dry kibbles in front of him and he'd eat it.

    • Gold Top Dog

    Agreed that there is absolutely nothing wrong with "people food" so long as it is HEALTHY people food and not processed, chemical laden stuff.  I actually cook.  I don't use the premade sauces, or entrees so whatever I serve my humans, my dogs can eat, unless it contains onion.  I don't allow ham simply because I don't like all the stuff that's in ham, but we will occassionally have some.  The dogs do not.  And, its random when they might get a bit of something from our table.

    I used to homecook for my dogs.  One meal of kibble, one meal of homecooked each day. However, when we moved to the Deep South, homecooked was causing screaming diaheria, so we stopped that.  They do get at least one raw meal every week, pretty typically chicken, and the occassional bit of leftover whatever, but like Meg, they are expected to eat what is in their bowl or they just do without.

    That said, I wouldn't let a dog go without a meal for more than 3 days, but, it's the rare dog who will push the envelope that far.

    • Gold Top Dog

     Teaching your dog to eat

    This works well for picky eaters. I, however, leave the bowl down for 15 minutes rather then 5 seconds as stated in the article. 

    Keep in mind, the 'grocery store' foods have added flavorings and such. The higher end kibble usually doesn't.

    • Gold Top Dog

     15 minutes, LOL! Tootsie, has it gone in about 5 minutes or less.

    • Gold Top Dog

    joyfullmom2
    ............the people that we got her from fed her human food

     

       Jessie gets a home cooked meal daily, and dry food for her other meals. She eats the dry food as eagerly as the cooked. Perhaps the issue with your dog is that she's adjusting to a new home and may be nervous and reluctant to eat something different than what she's used to having. The gas she's experiencing is probably from changing her food too soon; you're supposed to take about a week to change foods. Giving her a probiotic should help the gas. If she's eating the Purina One Beyond, I'd leave her on it for awhile, then try switching her to something better in a few months.

    • Gold Top Dog
    Just a note (in addition to everyone's good advice) - I buy my kibbles from a semi-fancy pet store, and they have some arrangement with the dog food manufacturers such that every bad of food is guaranteed. If the dog doesn't like the food, you can bring it back for a full refund - even if half the bag is already eaten. You might try an upscale dog food store that has that sort of guarantee - explain your situation, and see what they recommend. Best of luck!!