should we take a class or hire a trainer?

    • Gold Top Dog

    should we take a class or hire a trainer?

    So Sammy is pretty well-behaved, but there are still a few pesky traits I am trying to work on.  I'd tried clicker training him in the past and he's terrified of the clicker.  I'd still like to try clicker training, but I've tried click pens and jar lids and anything else softer sounding and it didn't work.  I've tried to do positive reinforcement with praise, but it's slow going.  He's a smart dog, he could do so much more, I think, if we used a clicker since then less depends on my timing, etc. 

    So I know the names of a good trainer or two, one of which I used in the past for something a little more important, but I'm not sure I want to pay $70/hr for her to come out again.  There is a drop-in class by another very good trainer, but it's 30 miles away and it's held in a grooming shop -- Sammy is aggressive towards intact males, so while a class a the humane society doesn't pose a risk since there aren't any intact males, I've afraid of a grooming business. Although the aggression is something else I'd like to work on with Sammy, it isn't a high priority since we don't see that many intact males day-to-day.  It's also hard to work on if

    There's a clicker class we could sign up for, but it might be a waste of money if he's too scared of it.  So any recommendations on my next course of action?  Should I really hire a trainer and spend a fortune, or should I try a drop in class if I tell the instructor about his potential aggression?  Or just give up, LOL?

    • Silver

    It sounds like Sammy has a bit going on in the shyness department.  I would opt for the group class at the humane society to help socialize him.  There would be enough people there to get you in contact with other people, and just keep opening up your contacts, wider, and wider.....I noticed you are from Western PA.  Is this a rural area? 

    Treat, treat, treat, click, treat, treat, treat, treat, click....and by treat I mean  CHICKEN....ummmmm hot dog.....um YUMMY stuff, not your run of the mill milk bone.  It's gotta be so good that he learns to 1st ignore the clicker then love the clicker.  ALL dogs are at first nervous of that loud noise....it is our job to teach them to associate it with a good sound.  There are good books online cheap at Amazon about clicker training.

    It's funny, I used to have a foster brindle staffy mix who was also nervous of the clicker......maybe a brindle thing?  She got over it quick, though....

    • Gold Top Dog

    He is sometimes shy, and we should work on it more, but I don't want to take basic obedience over, the next highest level is during the week and I'm not sure about the cilcker class since I dont know if we could get over his issues with it by then.  Maybe I will look for classes outside the humane society anyway, since the basic obedience classes aren't all +R -- the one we took last year made us use a choke collar. 

     We do use high-value treats.... of course this dog would go nuts for his kibble, but we do use sausage and the like.  I even homemade him some treats he goes bonkers over.  unfortunately sometime treats are too good and he's too busy thinking about the FOOD! LOL. 

    I will try again, start with something quieter than the clicker and see if maybe I can slowly work him up.

    Oh, and though I say Western PA it's only because I'm weird about people knowing exactly where I'm from -- I'm near pittsburgh it just turns out that all the good, highly recommended trainers are on the other side of the city or something.

    • Silver

    Hmmm, yes the first few times, just worry about the click and food, not any other aspect of training...no sit, no anything.  Try hotdogs, etc.  even feed every bit of his kibble dinner that way.....  At first, you are "training" the click......

    I would not recommend any class that uses a choke.