What to buy?

    • Bronze

    What to buy?

    Ok, I've been feeding my 18 months old Border Collie Eagle Pack for a little while now, first she was on Original Adult formula, which had Pork and Chicken, then we switched her to Power formula, which has similar but more chicken than pork. Now I want to take her off that and I was wondering whether to go to the Holistic Fish and Oatmeal or Holistic Chicken.
     
    :)
    • Gold Top Dog
    If your dog is doing well on one formula, stick with it for awhile before switching...no need to change without a reason [;)]
    • Bronze
    We are want to take her off the Power Formula because it's too much for her. It's for much more active dogs. We only put her on that to bulk her up a little, but we only wanted to do that for a short period. The reason we don't want to go back to the Original Adult Formula is because I don't particulary want to feed her pork.
    • Silver
    The Holistic Chicken has pork meal listed as its 6th ingredient ([linkhttp://www.eaglepack.com/pages/ep_hs_chicken.html]http://www.eaglepack.com/pages/ep_hs_chicken.html[/link]) so if it is a concern, the Holistic Fish would be more suitable as it does not have pork ([linkhttp://www.eaglepack.com/pages/ep_fish_oatmeal.html]http://www.eaglepack.com/pages/ep_fish_oatmeal.html[/link]).
    • Gold Top Dog
    Why do you feel pork is an issue? Just curious.
     
    I love the holistic fish, which I feed my Chi's in their rotation and feed my beagles (active field trial dogs) the Original formula. They all do fine on it.
    • Gold Top Dog
    I mix up the Eagle formulas,,,having 2 different bags going at the same time and switch off every week.
    Which ever forumula you like, buy. Slowly switch your dog from one to the other if she is not used to eating different food.
    I have NO issues with Pork in my dogs food at all. I don't know why anyone would. Eagle is great because it DOES have different meat souces in it...that is of course unless you dog has an issue with certain meats..which most don't!
    • Gold Top Dog
    After some research on the diet these dogs would have been fed in the old country, and discussions with some old timey working collie folks, I made some revisions in my Border collies' diet.   I added grains back in (I had been fairly strictly grainless previously) and switch between mostly oatmeal in the winter and mostly barley in the summer.  This approach made a surprisingly big difference in my Border collies, especially the for the periennially skinny, picky, hard keepers. 

    I also look for significant amounts of fish - and I rotate every so often to a food that is pretty much primarily some specific fish meal (like salmon, trout, menhaden, etc).  Fish is a big part of the diet in the northern countries, including the northern UK where the BC was developed.  I also add in fresh or canned fish once or twice a week no matter what kibble they are getting.

    I avoid corn like the plague, as do most progressive trial competitors and trainers.  The BC metabolism and nervous stomach just isn't well adapted to the slow process of digesting maize.

    This approach is in addition to their main meal, which is whole fresh raw meats and bones - so I don't worry too much about lamb versus chicken or pork - I just look for the fish and the seasonal grain, and avoid corn.  I also don't worry about other ingredients like sweet or white potato that are in addition to the key grain, as long as there's nothing really junky in there and the oatmeal or barley is high enough on the list to make a difference.

    Whew.  Oh, it's a great idea to switch foods around like you are doing.  BCs can play mind games and one of their favorite is manipulating feeding routines.[8|]
    • Bronze
    Thankyou you so much Brookcove. You're advice was great! I really appreciate it. I'm am starting to try and switch her back to raw again and that was a great help :)
     
     "BCs can play mind games and one of their favorite is manipulating feeding routines"  
     
    So yours play mind games too?!?! lol
     
    Oh and just a quick question, have you been over to the Behaviour, Acting out and Strange stuff section? There's a question there no one has been able to help me out with....