new site to check out

    • Gold Top Dog

    new site to check out

    I saw this site   [linkhttp://www.dogfoodanalysis.com/dog_food_reviews/]http://www.dogfoodanalysis.com/dog_food_reviews/[/link] 
    in a post on the dog forum site. It rates a lot of the foods everyone talks about on here, I think you'll be suprised to where some of the foods rate. I was!!! 
    • Gold Top Dog
    I really don't like that site....I don't think the person who made that site knows all that they are talking about.  They say alot of things about certain foods that is not necessarily true.  They are also obviously biased when it comes to grain-free foods, and falsely state that they are "not appropriate for puppies" which isn't true.  
    • Puppy
    Interesting site, thanks for sharing.
    • Gold Top Dog
    Is it me, or is regular Innova not even listed?
    • Gold Top Dog
    The grainfree foods are NOT appropriate for some pups....the large breed pups to be precise
     
    Dang it, I hit the return and the darned thing posted.  I wasn't DONE yet!
     
    Many of the foods listed ARE on the WDD best food list, but some shown are not.
    • Gold Top Dog
    Innova regular is there, 1st page 2nd from the bottom
    • Gold Top Dog
      This person is very biased and appears a bit ignorant to me about grains and such.
     
    What he/she doesn't realize is that not all dogs do well on the top 'holistic' foods. They just don't!   I am trying to not be offended by her site but it is just one-sighted and very closed minded in my opinion.
     
     
    • Gold Top Dog
    Okay,,,what don't I understand here?  Who is rating the food?
     
    I'm not buying it thats for sure.
    For one thing, it looks like another commercial for T. O.
     
    In the conversation about large breed puppies,,, Linda Arndt who has studied raising Great Danes for many years  recommends both Eagle Pack Natural or Large Breed Puppy food,,,both of which have oatmeal, rice and corn. She picks these two formulas for them over the holistic formulas.