calliecritturs
Posted : 5/29/2009 7:24:29 PM
Welcome to the wonderful world of "medical opinion" -- it DOES differ. And it's impacted by the vet's experience, education, and their "leaning" as to holistic, traditional, etc. It can even be influenced in large part by that vet's personal experience and clients -- I know MY 'regular' vet has changed several of his treatment protocols in light of things that have happened with my dogs, and IMHA in particular. He deals differently with chemicals and which companies he uses and trusts.
It's not easy for laypeople like us to really understand that amount of trust a vet has to put in the pharmaceutical companies they deal with. Because of the way they are educated essentially they really are trained the X mg of ABC drug given to 75% of those studied is supposed to have a "positive effect". But then when they are confronted with a dog who wound up getting IMHA from too many vaccines or chemicals it can really rock a vet's world IF THEY LET IT.
That's why a lot of vets don't even ASK whether the dog has had vaccinations or whatever ... they really don't want to KNOW the cause. They simply want to 'treat'. And that can be darned hard.
Most grains will create or exacerbate "inflammation" in the body -- that's not something typically subscribed to by regular "allopathic" vets mostly because most vet schools are primarily supported grant-wise by companies that manufacture Science Diet, IV formulas, etc. -- these are foods they USE in vet school to rule out "owner caused error" and it's a constant for them.
BUT they all contain grain ... so if you take that away from an allopathic vet they're at a loss because other foods aren't "studied" or aren't a known quantity to them.
It's the most holistic leanings that have brought out these ideas -- TCVM in particular is heavy into foods -- not just grains causing inflammation but things like chicken actually causing "heat" (which is inflammation) in the body. A healthy dog can often eat it without problem. But not other dogs.
But this is also why some dogs are erroneously categorized as having "chicken allergy" when it's not an allergy -- it's either an intolerance OR it's simply that the chicken exacerbated inflammation that was already developing in the body.
But if you look closely at Dr. Dodd's website -- she's also going to tell you that light/white colored dogs (like buffy coat or parti-colored cockers like Tessy and Billy) are almost hard-wired for IMHA. MUCH higher prevalence of dogs of a light coat color having IMHA than darker ones.