corvus
Posted : 8/10/2007 2:53:18 AM
I've never owned either BC or Kelpie. And I never will. I could never cope with that kind of intensity. I like my dogs to be laid back. I wouldn't want to get any more intense than a corgi.
However, I have known quite a lot of BCs and Kelpies. I've had friends that had one or the other throughout my life and both breeds are pretty common over here. You meet good ones and bad ones, although mostly the bad ones are just bored, frustrated ones.
I've been dubious of the so-called 'pet line' of Kelpies, having met some working lines working on a sheep station and not being able to imagine a happier, more content dog. However, I will reluctantly admit that there are Kelpies that aren't miserable as urban pets. Provided they get tons of exercise. And I've met a whole lot of kelpie crosses that make ace pets. My mother has one. Jill is crossed with a Boxer, and has lost the Kelpie focus somewhere along the line. She's a complete ditz, but it's thrilling to watch her catch frisbees.
Working line Kelpies are incredible dogs that fill me with awe, as well. I've never seen a more agile dog. They hop over 5ft fences without pausing to crouch and measure the distance. And of course, they're famous for running along the backs of the sheep. I don't think many Australians see true working Kelpies. Anyway, if you've got the time to keep them running for a few hours a day, they are great little dogs. They are just so smart and devoted, but they're workaholics and they're not happy if they haven't got something to do. Working Kelpies are chained or kennelled if there aren't enough sheep to work, because otherwise they go off and find some to work on their own, which usually results in dead sheep, either from exhaustion or being piled up in a corner where the bottom ones suffocate. It's hard to fathom just how desperately they need to work until you've seen them at it. Thankfully, pet lines are not quite that driven, but it's still a breed you really have to work with a lot to keep it happy. But they will apply themselves to anything you could imagine to teach them, so if that's what you're into, I think it's a really rewarding experience. I do like their cuddles, though. [
]